Tampilkan postingan dengan label Medicaid. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Medicaid. Tampilkan semua postingan

Selasa, 19 September 2017

Another Round of Zombie TrumpCare

Another Round of Zombie TrumpCare

Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 50


We might have thought that the Republicans would give up on repealing the Affordable Care Act (ACA)  - since they have come up with no alternative that would not lead to tens of millions more uninsured. Many of their proposals would paradoxically increase the cost of health care – whether through increasing premium subsidy cost by eliminating subsidies that decrease out of pocket costs for the poor, by removing minimum medical loss ratios, or removing prohibitions on physician ownership of ambulatory facilities.

But Graham-Cassidyis here – and it’s been blessed by “moderates” like Dean Heller.  John McCain and Lindsey Graham are best friends -- so he might just vote for this bill.   and Bill Cassidy is a physician from Louisiana,  a state that just over 400,000 new residents with its Medicaid expansion, and decreased the uninsured rate from 21.7% to 12.7%.   


The bill would make massive cuts in Medicaid –much like the other plans that the CBO projected would lead to loss of insurance by more than 20 million Americans.  It would change funding for both Medicaid and exchange subsidies to be a block grant to states – and redistribute the smaller pot of money from states that had expanded Medicaid to those which did not.   It would allow states to waive the essential benefits and the insurance reforms of the ACA –so goodbye to protections for the sick.  It would allow catastrophic health plans and mini-med health plans, prohibit any tax credits to any plan that covered abortions, and explicitly allow states to impose work requirements for Medicaid beneficiaries.   The individual mandate would lapse- making the insured pool sicker and therefore increasing health care premiums.

The R’s have less than two weeks to get a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) score and an approval from the Senate Parliamentarian to pass this egregious bill under the “reconciliation” procedure that requires only 50 votes (with VP Mike Pence as a tiebreaker).  But they can do it – and the pressure on that 50th Republican Senator to not be the one who prevented this travesty will be massive.

Some argue that state based programs are better than a federal program because states are able to be more nimble and innovative, and what’s good for Massachusetts is simply not what is good for Mississippi.    Here are four reasons why moving Medicaid to state block grants is a terrible public policy idea.

1.     Medicaid spending spikes during economic recessions – and the feds can run a deficit but the states cannot. So block granting this program (even if it were not woefully underfunded) doesn’t make economic sense.
2.     Nineteen states have not expanded Medicaid given the option with almost no state contribution– proving that their politicians are simply not committed to addressing the problem of uninsurance.   In Alabama a family of four cannot qualify for Medicaid unless their income is less than $4000 a year.   I’m not sure what makes us think that the state would be any more likely to use these new funds to bolster care for the poor.   
3.     We want more labor flexibility – especially in an environment with low unemployment.  Medicaid eligibility rules changing at the state line doesn’t help this.
4.     States are not especially adept at technology  - and many states (including well-meaning blue states) wasted scads of money trying to set up their exchanges only to throw their hands in the air and opt for joining the federal exchange.  Technology will be key to sending all possible dollars toward health care –and not toward administrative costs.

Many governors would like a big block grant.  Money is fungible –and they could use that block grant to supplant other funds the state previously spent on public health or health care and free up those dollars to go to other priorities.   We would likely see regressive tax cuts and giveaways to well-connected hospitals.  

I’m hopeful that Graham-Cassidy is here too late to upend the health insurance market.  But I’m not sure.  And I’m worried.

Senin, 11 September 2017

CHIP program in jeopardy



Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 8.9 million


This is the Congressional imperative that we just don't hear enough about.  Sure, there is the debt ceiling to keep us from defaulting on our national obligations, and the budget to keep us from a government shutdown.  And we definitely need to provide relief for the victims of Hurricanes Harvey and Irma. 

But we don't hear nearly enough about the Children's Health Insurance Program, CHIP, which provides coverage for 8.9 million kids.   Its authorization is up at the end of this month, and states will start running out of resources for CHIP by December.   CHIP was co-authored by Orrin Hatch and  has earned wide bipartisan support in its past reauthorizations - but Washington is strangely silent on this program.

CHIP was initially created after the failure of "HillaryCare" in the later Clinton administration; since its initiation, the rate of uninsurance among children has declined from 13.9% to 4.5%.

The Trump Budget proposed a 2 year extension of CHIP - but would have cut federal subsidies by 38% ($16.7 to 12 billion from FY 2017 to FY 2018).   Clearly - you can't provide coverage for the same number of kids with over 1/3 less funds.

It's a no-brainer to reauthorize CHIP, without the Trump-recommended draconian cuts.  When states had greater discretion to exclude children from the program (before the Affordable Care Act increased funding in 2010) often offered little access; in Arizona, the waiting list for CHIP was 5 years long!  Some "blue" states would be likely to move children to Medicaid (where federal expense would be the same or higher, assuming that the Republican Congress does not change Medicaid to block grants). "Red" states would either leave children uninsured or move them to exchange plans. These have high deductibles and aren't appropriate for families with few resources.

Children are inexpensive to insure (yes - less than $2000 per insured!)  Better access to medical care in childhood can lead to better health for a lifetime.   The CHIP population can benefit from the two medical interventions that actually save money (childhood immunization and birth control).  An no one can "blame" kids for their poverty. 

For those who want universal access to health care - we should guarantee it first for kids.  For those who want to be most cost-effective, we should purchase health care for kids using a Medicaid fee schedule. For those who want to have states control most policy decisions - CHIP is a program that allows substantial differences from state to state.

I'm hopeful that CHIP reauthorization will be attached to a must-pass bill that does not include a poison pill - one so that Republicans and Democrats can both endorse.   I'm worried the clock is running out.









Jumat, 14 Juli 2017

Compromise is hard when there is no agreement about goals

Compromise is hard when there is no agreement about goals


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 4
 

The new revised  Republican Senate health care bill is worse than the last iteration of the Better Care Reconciliation Act.
 
  • It will still cause devastating cuts in Medicaid - an incredibly valuable program that finances delivery for 45% of deliveries, 60% of nursing home stays and a substantial portion of the costs of substance abuse treatment.  
  • It is worse in that it allows insurance plans to sell non-compliant health plans - and allows the healthy to use health savings accounts or federal subsidies to purchase these skimpy plans.  That will lead to even more of the young and healthy skipping out of comprehensive health plans -and price more of the old and sick out of the market
  • It adds a little to subsidies for the near-poor - but not enough for most of them to be able to purchase health insurance that has affordable premiums and out of pocket costs that are income-appropriate
  • It puts an inadequate amount into high risk pool funding - and distributes this to the states, which historically have failed at setting up effective high cost pools
  • It puts some dollars into opioid programs, but decimating the Medicaid program will offset the good that comes from this.
  • It would allow many Americans to be in health plans that would not cover essential benefits - so that the funding for those benefits would be threatened for those who need them.
  • Separate Republican bills would prohibit the IRS from enforcing the individual mandate, which would further erode the health of those in the exchange and lead to higher prices and potential "death spiral."

A group of Democratic House members have put forward their plan to "fix" Obamacare.   This bill is thoughtful and would represent a real step forward.   It includes

  • Commitment to paying the cost sharing reductions going forward
  • Higher amount of subsidies to attract the healthy to the exchange markets, with aggressive marketing and potentially changing the open enrollment cycle to tax refund season
  • Enforcement and potential increase in the individual mandate penalties
  • Permanent reinsurance fund to protect health plans from the costs of enrolling the highest risk members
  • An ill-defined mechanism to allow older pre-65 Americans to "buy into" Medicare, which would also help take some of the most expensive patients off the individual exchange markets.

What's striking about these two efforts is that there is essentially no overlap. The Republicans seek to decrease taxes (on the rich) and decrease the role of the government in both financing and regulating health care, even though the US health care system is a failed experiment in leaving the system to only a very lightly regulated market in the eyes of many economists.  The Democrats want to insure affordable access to health care for all - and are willing to do this by increasing the role of government - even though all those with current levers of power adamantly oppose this and are ideologically and politically committed to moving in the opposite direction.  

It's really hard to compromise when there is no overlap in what each party is looking for!

I've been thinking hard about where there could be room for compromise, and frankly, I don't see much.   A few preliminary thoughts:

Concept
Party Positions
Challenge
Decrease regulations that prevent less expensive practitioners from providing services
Republicans are often against regulations - and these are regulations that genuinely could increase market effectiveness
The doctor, dentist, and even nurse lobbies are adamantly opposed and claim that these regulations protect consumers.
 
Further, these are largely state regulations, and federal preemption of state regulation is fraught with problems
Increase enforcement of antitrust laws, as provider consolidation is a major reason for unit cost increases
Democrats in general are more supportive of antitrust enforcement; Republicans are more likely to worry about government interference
Providers have a huge amount of political influence, and oppose such enforcement
Offer national reinsurance  at a low attachment point, so that the care beyond $50 or $75,000 annually would be the responsibility of the federal government
Republicans are putting tens of billions into high risk pools -although they would likely be loathe to use these funds for a federal program.  
 
Democrats have proposed this before (Kerry 2004 health care plan).

This could also help decrease risk selection in health plans, and would be a relief to employers who struggle with high cost cases. 
Insurance companies (and reinsurers) would not necessarily like losing this portion of their current business.

Ideally the federal government would have the states administer this through their existing Medicaid non-managed care contracts, and could fund this 100% to avoid state rejection
Increase funding for anti-fraud efforts
These pay for themselves, and no one is in favor of fraud and abuse!
Some will again worry of government overreach, and the Trump Administration is in the process of disassembling regulatory apparatus.

Some of the more extravagant claims of fraud include simple coding errors (like a woman being miscoded as a male and then a delivery being considered "fraud").

There is a ceiling of potential savings - though we are nowhere close to that yet.
 




That's all I've got. Just four rows.   It's not much to work off of - and none of these are slam-dunks.  This highlights just how hard it will be to develop a compromise in these polarized times.

Senin, 10 Juli 2017

More bad ideas in health care policy

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is $3 trillion

Source   The Urban Institute has used its microsimulation model to estimate the impact of the BCRA on un-insurance rates.

The Senate continues to work on the Better Care Reconciliation Act -- and some commentators think that the chances of this bill passing are receding.   The bill remains a travesty - removing health care access from tens of millions, to fund  tax cuts tilted strongly to the superrich.   Some commentators have ideas about how to reform the Republican's health care reform. 

Many of these ideas are well-meaning, but could worsen health care access and cost.  Here's my critique of two proposals of how the Republicans should proceed. 

Ross Douthat suggested that the Republicans "go small" and limit the health care bill to canceling the individual mandate and capping federal Medicaid expenditures.    His proposal has four prongs
  • Replace  the individual mandate with a continuous coverage requirement, so that those who didn't purchase health insurance would be "locked out" during a waiting period.   If they had a medical emergency during the lockout period, tough luck.    Douthat points out this would cost only $38 billion in foregone federal revenue, but doesn't address the increased cost of insurance when the healthiest opt out.
  • Repeal various taxes, and allow higher contributions to health care savings accounts.  This would make the pharmaceutical industry, the health insurance industry, and the medical device industry happy.  The HSA accounts tend to benefit the well-off disproportionately, but at least this prong doesn't impair the existing market
  • Maintain stabilization funds provided to states to help provide coverage to the sickest patients - a genuinely good idea
  • Fund all of the above by imposing limits on Federal Medicaid contribution.  Since the need for Medicaid goes up with recessions, and almost every state has to balance its budget, this would mean there would be contraction rather than expansion of Medicaid during the next recession.

Peter Suderman thinks the Republicans should start from scratch - and put forward big, bold principles
  • Stop saying that their goal is universal coverage (since their bills clearly move away from this anyway).  I appreciate the intellectual honesty here.  
  • Support unified, rather than the current fragmented, health care finance system.   In Suderman's formulation, the problem is a combination of the $250 billion annual tax break on employer sponsored health insurance and the existence of government funded systems like Medicare and Medicaid. 

    He doesn't say directly he would eliminate Medicare and Medicaid - but it's hard to see how moving to more private insurance would "unify" health care finance!  He complains that Medicaid "sidelines" the poor in "a system that many doctors won’t participate in because of low reimbursement rates."  Tell that to the parents of the 45% of babies in the US whose deliveries are paid for by Medicaid, or the 60+% of nursing home residents!   We need lower reimbursement rates if we want to lower the overall cost of health care. The real fragmentation in health care finance is on the private, market-oriented side of health care.
  • Promote supply side reforms that lead to the availability of lower cost health care.   He associates the huge increase in health care costs with Medicare - and advocates eliminating government rules and regulations that diminish innovation.   He's right in one sense.  We could increase health care affordability by eliminating rules which enforce "guild" systems where only a physician (or a nurse or a dentist) is allowed to perform a service that could be effectively provided by a lower cost professional or semi-professional often with the assistance of technology.   But instead he advocates removing restrictions on doctor-owned hospitals - which clearly increase total costs.


Health care costs about $3 trillion in the US, and we should seek ideas from both sides of the aisle.  But we should reject proposals that diminish coverage, or that would increase costs or drive the healthier out of the current insurance markets.  The current system has many faults.  But we can definitely make it worse. 

Selasa, 27 Juni 2017

Medicaid Matters!

 Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 74 million


The Congressional Budget Officehas weighed in on the Better Care Reconciliation Act - and concluded that 22 million Americans will lose access to health coverage in the Senate's health care bill.  Fifteen million of the newly uninsured will be kicked off Medicaid - more than were added during the ObamaCare expansion.

Medicaid is a much more important part of the health care system than many think - and plans to cut funds by as much as 50% will have an enormous impact not just on the poor, but on the elderly, the disabled, and those with mental illness.

The Kaiser Family Foundation has covered Medicaid comprehensively for years- here is their landing page.  Here's a link the New York Times explainer published last night.  Some important facts for this debate.

  1. Medicaid currently covers 20% of the US population, about 74 million, including most residents of nursing homes, 40% of those with disabilities, and 40% of children. Source
  2. Medicaid covers 45% of all deliveries in the US.   It covers 67% in Arkansas, 72% in New Mexico, and 65% in Louisiana.  Source
  3. Medicaid funds more than half of all long term care services Source  The New York Times reported that some nursing home residents might be kicked out of their residences.
  4. Medicaid expansion helped decrease uninsurance among children from 12% (2000) to 5% (2015) Source
  5. Medicaid coverage is associated with lower rate of financial distress, and increased use of preventive care.  Source
  6. Medicaid is the largest source of care for those seeking assistance for opioid abuse.
  7. Medicaid is the lowest cost way to expand access to medical care - largely due to very low fee schedules
  8. Medicaid funding needs are highest during economic downturns, making Federal funding critical to avoid gaps in coverage of the vulnerable during recessions.


Donald Trump promised no Medicaid cuts during the campaign, and Republican Senators and members of the Trump Administration were quoted this weekend denying that TrumpCare will require kicking people off the Medicaid rolls.

Speaking on CBS’s “Face the Nation,” Sen. Patrick J. Toomey (R-Pa.), claimed the Republican plan “will codify and make permanent the Medicaid expansion,” and added, “No one loses coverage.” His comments echoed those by Conway, who told “This Week,” “These are not cuts to Medicaid.”  Source

This is an unequivocal lie. 

You can't cut $800 billion out of Medicaid without decreasing the number of Americans covered.  The Senate bill would lead to massive displacement in American health care financing and delivery.    Rural hospitals would be threatened with closure. Community health centers would lose substantial funding. 

People will die.


Kamis, 25 Mei 2017

23 million to lose insurance under AHCA


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 23 million



The Congressional Budget Office report on the American Health Care Act dropped last night at the end of the East Coast business day -and the news is great according to Paul Ryan.


“This CBO report again confirms that the American Health Care Act achieves our mission: lowering premiums and lowering the deficit,” Ryan said in a statement. “It is another positive step toward keeping our promise to repeal and replace Obamacare.”

Pretty much everyone else with a brain demurs.

Highlights of the CBO analysis:

  • 23 million will lose their health insurance by 2026
  • 14 million would lose Medicaid coverage (and that's before the additional cuts in the Trump 2018 budget proposal
  • 1/6 of Americans live in areas where the unstable individual market would make purchase of insurance prohibitively expensive for those with preexisting illnesses - mainly in states that waived essential benefits.
  • 1 in 5 Americans under 65 will be uninsured by 2026
  • Lower premiums are purely driven by loss of coverage by older and sicker people, and by skimpier "coverage."   (Plans without maternity, mental health, and inpatient care are not really coverage, are they?)
  • The overwhelming majority of health care cuts fund tax cuts for the rich, for drug companies, and for insurers.  (Total tax cuts are $661 billion- while deficit reduction is only $119 billion)



Source

Source


Source