Tampilkan postingan dengan label ACA. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label ACA. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 06 Juli 2017

TrumpCare: Defective insurance plans to fleece policyholders




Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  49.5%


As Kim Jung Un fires ballistic missiles into the waters off Japan and Donald Trump encourages the right wing in Poland, the Senate continues to work under the cover of heavy secrecy on a bill to strip health care from tens of millions. 

But that's not enough.   In the name of free markets, Ted Cruz has suggested that insurance companies should be allowed to sell insurance plans that do not comply with pre-existing condition prohibitions or offer all ACA-required essential benefits  - as long as in each state they offer at least one plan that does comply with ACA requirements. 

Here's how this would work.   Insurers would offer one plan that complied with the Affordable Care Act.  This plan would  cover maternity (just think!), mental health services, ambulance rides, prescription drugs, and emergency rooms. (All of these requirements would be waived in the non-compliant plans).   The plan would be available for the same price to all comers, whether they were healthy or had preexisting illnesses.  The plan would be attractive to those at high risk - so it would have to have a high price.  It would also likely be saddled with the largest allowable deductibles and coinsurance - to discourage utilization and to keep the premium from being even higher.   

This plan is the definition of a "death spiral."  Insurers would offer compliant plans to gain the right to offer the less inclusive plans, which would be priced to sell.   Risk for having babies or taking expensive medicines would be transferred to individuals - as healthy members would no longer be subsidizing the sick.    Those with preexisting illnesses could choose between affording their housing or their health insurance. 

What would noncompliant insurance look like for those at low risk who could make it through the underwriting process to gain eligibility?  For starters, it would be cheap!   Five percent of the population represents49.5% of all medical costs - so you could design an insurance plan for 40% less if you could exclude those expensive patients - and still make a whopping profit.  But Mitch McConnell will focus on the lower prices, not he value of the available plans.     

However that noncompliant plan would be a bum deal.   It could be a "mini-med" plan which had a cap of a few thousand dollars - enough for an emergency room visit.  (These were banned by the ACA - but would be revived under Trumpcare).   It would exclude specialty medications which often cost $100,000 a year, and would not cover mental health services.  It would be designed to be unattractive to those with real needs -because that's how to make such a plan profitable.  Do you need maternity care?  Then buy a rider priced at the cost of delivery!


These plans would have very low "medical loss ratios."   Under the ACA, insurers must issue refunds if their administrative costs exceed 15-20%.   Those rebates would go away - and insurance company profitability would soar.   That's why health plans are ambivalent about TrumpCare.  They hate going back to offering plans designed to exclude coverage for the sick - but those profits are mighty attractive.

Even worse, the bottom 50% of the population represents under 3% of total costs.   Imagine how cheap the health plan catering to just the healthiest half of the population could be - while leaving room for healthy profits. 
  
We don't allow automakers to sell cars without bumpers.  We don't allow furniture makers to sell baby cribs that have risk of finger amputation or decapitation.  The government has a role in promoting public safety -and this role includes structuring markets to prevent the sale of defective or dangerous goods.  

There's no reason to allow the resurrection of insurance plans that fleece  policyholders and leave sick people with no coverage.  The Senate should reject this terrible idea.

Senin, 01 Mei 2017

 Republican Congressman crafts amendment so others can share experience of brutal medical bills

Republican Congressman crafts amendment so others can share experience of brutal medical bills


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $1 million


Here are the first three paragraphs of an Associated Press article from earlier today:

New Jersey Rep. Tom MacArthur has experienced personal tragedy and understands the need for health insurance.

"I lost my mother at 4 years old. My father had no insurance and I watched him until I was in college pay off medical bills," says the two-term Republican lawmaker.

Years later, MacArthur suffered the anguish over the death of his 11-year-old daughter, Gracie. "We had over $1 million of medical bills. I had insurance, but I still had a lot of uncovered expenses, and it's brutal," he says.

Ironically, MacArthur has just proposed an amendment to the already outrageous American Health Care Act which would allow states to eliminate Affordable Care Act essential benefits and preexisting illness requirements as long as the state says that premiums will come down and it establishes a high risk pool for those who are denied insurance. 

This has been tried before – the high risk pools are always underfunded, and the premiums are so high that only those with the highest costs enroll.   So health insurance premiums come down for the healthy – and health insurance is unavailable practically for the sick.

The real story is that MacArthur has learned nothing from his family’s tragedies.

Sarah Kliff just published a profile of a single mom with three children who lost her home and savings due to medical bills before ObamaCare – and who lives in a county in Tennessee that has no insurers committed to exchange plans in 2018.   She’s weaning herself off health care, and telling her children what to do if she suddenly dies.  


Selasa, 28 Maret 2017

Republicans CAN save Obamacare!

Republicans CAN save Obamacare!

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 150,000


Obamacare has had more than its share of detractors, but it also has real problems.   Most of these are problems that could be addressed with straightforward legislation and thoughtful regulation -and now that the Trump Administration and Paul Ryan have stated that the ACA is the "law of the land," here is how they could address the ACA's problems.  Many of the solutions I'm noting here are anathema to conservatives - but perhaps there is hope. 

David Leonhardt noted today in the NY Times that the executive branch could easily destroy the individual markets - which serve those between 133% and 400% of the federal poverty level.   It could encourage more uncertainty or more adverse selection, and insurers will run.  Medicaid is harder to dislodge without 60 votes in the Senate.   It would be ironic  if the Republicans strangled the exchanges, which utilize private health insurance plans and were initially designed by conservatives at the Heritage Foundation, while they provided ongoing support for Medicaid, which is a government program with no free market elements.


Here are the major problems with the ACA, and what the Republicans could do to address these problems

Too few healthy people have enrolled.

The AHCA tried to solve this by allowing insurers to charge older people more. This might have chased away the old and sick - but on its own would not recruit a lot of young healthy folks.   To attract more of the young healthy into the exchanges:
  • Enforce the individual penalty (and make it larger)
  • Advertise!
  • Keep the rates low - perhaps through larger subsidies
  • Assure all that the cost sharing reductions will remain in place .  See Monday's post on this.   Good news is The Hill reports that senior Republicans are supporting this.

The out of pocket costs of health plans are too high, as are the premiums for those without subsidies.

Out of Pocket: The CSR helps those below 250% of FPL -these could be extended to higher incomes.  (They phase out at 250% of FPL - this could be at 400% or more).

Premium Costs: Subsidies for those under 400% of FPL are a big help.   But even those at 400% of FPL have a hard time affording premiums, especially in rural areas.  We could put in place a hard limit to portion of income that could be spent on premiums for a basic plan, making plans affordable for more.

Efforts to lower the overall costs of health care are critical here - that includes aggressive market-based payment reform, like bidding first for commodities (like durable medical equipment) and later for other medical services.  

The FDA could consider safety, efficacy, AND cost effectiveness.   That feels like more regulations- but if we want less expensive health care like the rest of the developed world, we need to control pharmaceutical costs.

We could think about price ceilings, perhaps as a percent of Medicare, too. This would diminish much of the effort currently spent on negotiation - and could allow more aggressive competition among health plans.   Health plan fragmentation would no longer allow exceptionally high prices.

Too few people are covered

Medicaid is the least expensive way to provide medical care for the poor and near poor.   19 states could expand Medicaid -- which would increase coverage by over 4 million.   This could also help take some pressure off of the exchanges, where those under 133% of FPL who had signed up had disproportionate illness - raising premiums for all exchange enrollees.  Of course this means that the government will pay - but it will do so at a reduced rate, and Medicaid programs have been exceptionally effective at providing health care to those with extreme needs.   Breaking news - Kansasis now (again) considering Medicaid expansion.   The State Senate passed  Medicaid expansion overwhelmingly last year but it was vetoed by Governor Sam Brownback.   This could cover 150,000 additional Kansans.


So- there it is. The big ACA problems - and how to fix them.   If the Republicans want to make the ACA's exchanges work - they can do it.  

Senin, 27 Maret 2017

The AHCA is dead, but Trump could still kill the ACA


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is Six



We can spend the weekend celebrating the failure of Congressional Republicans to repeal and replace Obamacare.   The American Health Care Act was ill-conceived, would have led to loss of insurance for 24 million, and would have led to higher health care costs and less meaningful health insurance coverage for additional millions – and it is dead.  For now.

But the opportunity to damage the Affordable Care Act remains. 

Salonhas an insightful piece today about how the Republicans have been undermining the ACA since it was passed.  Marco Rubio and others slipped a provision into a budget bill that gutted risk corridor payments to health plans that lost money in the ACA’s early years, when actuaries lacked enough claims to make good estimates of projected costs.   The federal government owed insurers $2.9 million, but only paid out $400,000.   This was a major reason for the failure of the COOP plans, and a lawsuit on this was dismissed last week.

There are many other ways that the Trump Administration can undermine the Affordable Care Act, and help fulfill Donald Trump’s predictions about the ACA “imploding” or “exploding.”   Today, I’ll focus on what the administration can do to undermine the law – and in a future post I’ll talk more about what it could do to make the law work better.  

1.      Stop paying insurance plans for the “cost reduction subsidy,” the CSR.   The ACA limits out of pocket spending for individuals at under 250% of the federal poverty limit, and the federal government writes a check to health plans to cover this expense.   The expense is not factored into premium costs.  But the House Republicans sued the Obama Administration - asserting that it could only pay these funds if they were appropriated.    A district court found for the House, and the Obama Administration lodged an appeal.   The Trump administration and Paul Ryan have asked the Appeals Court to delay hearing the case.  If the Trump Administration decides not to defend against this suit and to renege on payment to health plans – we’re going to see a mass exodus of insurers from the ACA marketplaces.

Source:



2.       Not enforce the employer mandate
One of the biggest impacts of the ACA was that it set standards for “minimum essential coverage,” and employers had to meet those standards or would be subject to penalties. These penalties were delayed by the Obama Administration (although it’s not clear they had the authority to do so.)  But there has been widespread belief that employers that did offer the ten essential benefits as required by each state, or had premiums that were unaffordable for their employees, would have to pay a penalty someday.  If it’s clear there will never be a penalty, we could lose many of the benefits of a national standard for employer sponsored health insurance.

3.      Not enforce the individual mandate
We need to have healthy people in the insurance pool, because insurance is wealth transfer from the healthy to the sick.   Many healthy people (yup – guys in their 20s) feel invincible – so there has to be some “stick” to encourage them to sign up for (and pay for) health insurance.   Hence the reviled mandate.  The Trump administration has already instructed the IRS not to collect data from individuals documenting health coverage.   Further moves to telegraph that the requirement is dead could help make all of the “death spiral” talk a reality. 

4.      Give states Medicaid waivers that allow them to sharply diminish the numbers of those covered, or the quality of the coverage.  Medicaid is the most cost effective way to cover the poor – and is far less expensive than commercial insurance, generally due to low provider fees.   States have asked for waivers to require work, to require more cost sharing, and to require more bureaucracy.   These efforts will push many away from Medicaid – which will lead to worse health outcomes and expose providers to bad debt.

5.      Cancel marketing plans.   The Affordable Care Act works to reduce uninsurance when there is aggressive marketing. The Trump Administration pulled ads at the end of the last enrollment period, and when they pulled ads, enrollment dropped.  The ACA only succeeds with robust enrollment.  It won’t work if the ACA is a closely guarded secret.

6.      Abandon payment reform.  Let’s face it- the real problem with the ACA is that health care is too expensive.  I don’t believe for a minute that payment reform will by itself cure our health care cost problem.  But I believe that aggressive experimentation with different payment models can help drive clinical transformation.  Medicare is a critical player in payment reform, and the efforts of CMS and CMMI (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation) have helped foment substantial payment reform on the commercial side.  However, if providers generally think that the Tom Price HHS doesn’t care for any payment reform, we could see a substantial drop in provider ACO activity.  Providers who continue to do what they have historically done are not going to help us control health care costs.  

It was easy for the Republicans to vociferously oppose the Affordable Care Act, but hard for them to agree on a meaningful alternative.   It was easier for the Democrats to oppose the poorly-drafted AHCA, and will be harder for them to push the executive branch to do effective rule-making and enforcement now that Ryan and Trump have agreed that the ACA is the "law of the land."


Additional sources for this post are articles by Margot Katz-Sanger of the New York Times, Anna Maria Barry-Jester of 538.comand Adam Cancryn and others of Politico.

Image (C) cmfu via Flickr Creative Common License  

Senin, 13 Maret 2017

The AHCA will lead to higher health care costs for individuals


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $1542
 
  
Source 
Over the weekend, Tom Price told Face the Nation " Nobody will be worse off financially" under the proposed Republican health plan.

This is simply not true.

Below is an representation of the change in refundable tax credits offered by the ACA compared to the AHCA.   You can see that for the most vulnerable of Americans, there is a huge decrease in the amount of subsidy available. Since the AHCA has no mechanism to lower prices or cost -this means that there will many Americans who will pay far more for health care.

There are a few with incomes above 400% of federal poverty level (FPL) who will gain slightly under the AHCA - but the worse affected will be:

  • Older Americans.  The ratio of premiums will go up to 5:1 from 3:1, and the subsidy will be only twice that of those under 35
  • Rural Americans.  Health care is more expensive in rural counties.  Subsidies are flat - and unrelated to premiums
  • Poor Americans. The AHCA does away with cost sharing reductions, so there is essentially no limit to how much of total earnings can be paid in health care.

Source

Kamis, 09 Maret 2017

I hate Obamacare!

I hate Obamacare!


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 7


There are a lot of things I hate about the Affordable Care Act.  

However, all of these will get dramatically worse if the American Health Care Act is passed.

1.      The ACA doesn’t cover enough people.  

The goal was to eliminate uninsurance.  First we removed the illegal immigrants, and then we allowed states the latitude not to expand Medicaid, which left millions with incomes under 133% of federal poverty level (FPL) to languish without insurance.


2.      The ACA exchange plans have excessive out of pocket costs.

Many have said “coverage is so stingy it isn’t even worth it.”  The maximum family deductible is $14,300!  It’s affordable for those with subsidies and eligible for the cost sharing reduction (CSR limits out of pocket costs for those at less than 250% of FPL), but it’s not affordable for others.

The AHCA will eliminate the CSR in 2019, so low income individuals won’t have a cap on total expenses based on their income. Subsidies will be lower – so the actuarial value of plans would have to go down unless the premiums shot up.  So if you hate your current deductible and coinsurance – with TrumpCare it will be worse.

3.      The ACA does too little (some say nothing) to control health care costs.

It’s true!  The ACA encourages payment reform through Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and expanded pilot programs.  But corralling all the interests groups to get this extra coverage passed in 2009 didn’t leave much room for cost control.

The AHCA will do nothing structurally to lower health care costs. Medicare will not negotiate for drugs in Medicare Part B, and Tom Price has been an opponent of any approach that could constrain physician income.  

4.      The ACA doesn’t do enough to get healthy people to enroll – so that the insurance pool is higher risk than it should be.

The Obama administration hoped 40% of enrollees would be under 35 –and it’s been only 28%

The AHCA will eliminate the individual mandate. The only penalty for not having insurance for any length of time would be a one year 30% extra premium.  This is not going to be a great way to convince the young invincibles to purchase health insurance!
 
5.      The ACA left too many decisions (like Medicaid expansion and essential benefits) to the states.

And many states did not act in the best interests of their residents.  In Alabama, adults are not eligible for Medicaid unless they are at 16% of the FPL- under $4000 for a family of four!  States could have improved their economies, their budgets, and their tax revenues by expanding Medicaid, but 19 still haven’t.

The AHCA will unload Medicaid onto the states altogether, and fund it with $377 billion less over a decade.

6.      Purchasing health insurance through the ACA is needlessly complex

The Obama administration misfired with the initial healthcare.gov launch – and worked hard to make enrollment easy. But it remains a complex chore, and many need help from brokers and enrollment counselors.

The AHCA will make shopping well-nigh impossible by eliminating the “metal” tiers – so insurance companies will go back to creating non-comparable products to seek to selectively attract healthier enrollees.

7.      Even with the ACA, funding for public health in the US is scandalously low.

The ACA included extra $1 billion a year in prevention funds – 1/8 of the CDC budget.


The AHCA will eliminate this funding.  But simply calling the next Ebola outbreak “fake news” won’t be enough to save lives.  



So maybe I don’t love Obamacare.  It’s deeply flawed.

But I’m discovering how much I love gridlock