Tampilkan postingan dengan label risk selection. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label risk selection. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 22 September 2017

Why are exchange premiums rising so fast?



Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 17%
 

Kaiser Family Foundation and the Health Education Research Trust release a comprehensive review of employer sponsored health insurance each September - and that report dropped this week.   One of the takeaways is that employer sponsored health insurance is increasing in cost at a rate dramatically less than the Affordable Care Act exchanges.  This was picked up by Kaiser Health News (Phil Galewitz briefly quotes me) and by the New York Times.  The graphic above shows a 17% gap between the rate of premium increase for employer sponsored plans compared to individually-purchased exchange plans. 

Employers are making some important efforts to improve the cost effectiveness of care.  This includes narrow high performance networks, earlier intervention with metabolic syndrome, and centers of excellence.  But there are other big reasons why the costs of employer sponsored insurance, especially large self-insured companies, are more stable than the costs of the exchanges.

  1. Risk selection
    Employees tend to be healthier than those purchasing insurance on the exchanges.   They often leave their employment if they get exceptionally sick.  But more importantly, an employer offers coverage to all of her employees - and the 10% with the highest risk all take up the offer, but they are "diluted" by the fact that 70 or so percent of all employees accept insurance- so members in the top decile of risk only represent 1/7 of the total population.  Insurance takeup at smaller employers is lower - often closer to 30% - so those in the top decile of risk could represent 1/3 of the insured population.    It's even worse in the individual market - where the top decile of risk could represent as much as a majority of all insured.   Individual markets are especially susceptible to "death spirals," where the increasing cost of insurance chases away all potential low-risk subscribers.  

    The individual mandate should help keep younger and healthier people in the risk pool - but the Trump Administration has signaled that it is loath to enforce this. 

    The Trump Administration also cut 90% of the advertising budget and has
    forced firing of most of the health care navigators across the states by not approving budgets.   Sick people are likely to find their way to the exchanges - while we are not making it easy for those without a large illness burden to do the same
     
  2. Government Interference
    The
    Congressional Budget Office notes that rate increases of 15% on the ACA exchange markets could be related to the uncertainty about whether the Cost Sharing Reduction (CSR) payments will continue through the next calendar year.  The Trump Administration has offered mixed messages on this - and insurers have to build rates as if they will not get these payments at some point in the future.

    CMS has also
    used ACA funds to produce material discouraging ACA enrollment - which can lead to market confusion and worsening risk profile of those who do enroll. 
     
We don't adequately appreciate that the Affordable Care Act has actually helped lower the cost of employer sponsored health insurance, too.    The ACA included decreases in the rate of increase of Medicare fee schedules.   Most commercial health plans pay fee for service for care delivered - and these fee schedules are almost all based on Medicare fee schedules.  As the Medicare fee schedule stays closer to flat - it's easier to avoid raising the commercial fee schedules as well. 

Rabu, 23 November 2016

Essential benefits prevent risk selection


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 10

It would be loopy to eliminate essential benefits 

There’s been a lot of talk about “essential benefits” in the Affordable Care Act.  These benefits are required of all health plans - not just those health plans in the Obamacare exchanges.  Mandated benefits are a double-edged sword. They make sure that certain services are covered, and that people are not duped into buying health plans that would provide them with little coverage if they get sick. They mandate coverage for preventive services that otherwise might be underused.  BUT mandates make premiums more expensive. First dollar coverage of certain essential services decreases consumer price sensitivity, and mandated coverage likely means that deductibles and cost sharing for other services goes up. 

The essential health benefits  mandated by the ACA are:

    • Outpatient care (like doctor’s office visits)
    • Emergency room visits
    • Inpatient care
    • Maternity and newborn care
    • Mental health and substance abuse care
    • Prescription drugs
    • Rehabilitation services
    • Laboratory services
    • Preventive services
    • Pediatric services


These are not especially controversial - no one thinks that a health plan that excludes emergency room services is “real” health insurance.   Before the Affordable Care Act, 2/3 of health plans sold on the individual markets excluded maternity care.  That allowed those not expecting to have a baby to pay lower rates -but it made coverage that included maternity care prohibitively expensive.

The essential benefits are actually an important effort to decrease risk selection. Since all health plans must cover these essential benefits - no health plans will suffer from recruiting patients who are “shopping” for services they know they will need.   Eliminating the essential benefits would allow health plans to “innovate” in health plan design, but it’s likely that most innovation would be seeking positive risk selection.

Many states have mandates for health plans to cover what they judge to be essential services -but the Employee Retirement and Income Security Act (ERISA, 1973) exempts employer-sponsored self-insured plans from these state mandates.  The Affordable Care Act was an important national effort to be sure that Americans had access to meaningful coverage and health plans were not using plan design to attract positive risk. 

Some object to the requirement that health plans cover birth control, as it is an essential preventive service for women.  Note that birth control is one of the few medical services that is cost saving, so that eliminating this requirement would make health plans more expensive.  Further, long acting reversible contraception has helped dramatically decrease the abortion rate in the US. Still, many object to this requirement.  I suspect few of those objecting are women of childbearing age. 

The ACA allows reasonable cost sharing for non-preventive services, and allows health plans to limit coverage for essential services to in-plan providers.  If i had my druthers I’d do away with the cost -free “annual wellness exam,” which is wasteful.  And I might allow some cost sharing for preventive services - but these are minor quibbles. 

But essential services should be covered by all health plans, and eliminating these coverage requirements would be bad public policy.