Tampilkan postingan dengan label public health. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label public health. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 09 Maret 2017

I hate Obamacare!

I hate Obamacare!


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 7


There are a lot of things I hate about the Affordable Care Act.  

However, all of these will get dramatically worse if the American Health Care Act is passed.

1.      The ACA doesn’t cover enough people.  

The goal was to eliminate uninsurance.  First we removed the illegal immigrants, and then we allowed states the latitude not to expand Medicaid, which left millions with incomes under 133% of federal poverty level (FPL) to languish without insurance.


2.      The ACA exchange plans have excessive out of pocket costs.

Many have said “coverage is so stingy it isn’t even worth it.”  The maximum family deductible is $14,300!  It’s affordable for those with subsidies and eligible for the cost sharing reduction (CSR limits out of pocket costs for those at less than 250% of FPL), but it’s not affordable for others.

The AHCA will eliminate the CSR in 2019, so low income individuals won’t have a cap on total expenses based on their income. Subsidies will be lower – so the actuarial value of plans would have to go down unless the premiums shot up.  So if you hate your current deductible and coinsurance – with TrumpCare it will be worse.

3.      The ACA does too little (some say nothing) to control health care costs.

It’s true!  The ACA encourages payment reform through Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services and expanded pilot programs.  But corralling all the interests groups to get this extra coverage passed in 2009 didn’t leave much room for cost control.

The AHCA will do nothing structurally to lower health care costs. Medicare will not negotiate for drugs in Medicare Part B, and Tom Price has been an opponent of any approach that could constrain physician income.  

4.      The ACA doesn’t do enough to get healthy people to enroll – so that the insurance pool is higher risk than it should be.

The Obama administration hoped 40% of enrollees would be under 35 –and it’s been only 28%

The AHCA will eliminate the individual mandate. The only penalty for not having insurance for any length of time would be a one year 30% extra premium.  This is not going to be a great way to convince the young invincibles to purchase health insurance!
 
5.      The ACA left too many decisions (like Medicaid expansion and essential benefits) to the states.

And many states did not act in the best interests of their residents.  In Alabama, adults are not eligible for Medicaid unless they are at 16% of the FPL- under $4000 for a family of four!  States could have improved their economies, their budgets, and their tax revenues by expanding Medicaid, but 19 still haven’t.

The AHCA will unload Medicaid onto the states altogether, and fund it with $377 billion less over a decade.

6.      Purchasing health insurance through the ACA is needlessly complex

The Obama administration misfired with the initial healthcare.gov launch – and worked hard to make enrollment easy. But it remains a complex chore, and many need help from brokers and enrollment counselors.

The AHCA will make shopping well-nigh impossible by eliminating the “metal” tiers – so insurance companies will go back to creating non-comparable products to seek to selectively attract healthier enrollees.

7.      Even with the ACA, funding for public health in the US is scandalously low.

The ACA included extra $1 billion a year in prevention funds – 1/8 of the CDC budget.


The AHCA will eliminate this funding.  But simply calling the next Ebola outbreak “fake news” won’t be enough to save lives.  



So maybe I don’t love Obamacare.  It’s deeply flawed.

But I’m discovering how much I love gridlock

Kamis, 01 Desember 2016

Mismatch between opioid risk and needle exchanges

Deaths from Drug Overdoses and Automobile Accidents, US (annual)
Source (Boston Globe)

Opioid deaths are one reason that the US has been less successful at increasing life expectancy than other high income countries.  Drug abuse deaths -mostly from opiods, surpassed motor vehicle accidents as a cause of deaths in the US last year.  These deaths are disproportionately concentrated in distressed communities - including inner cities (the ones that haven't been gentrified) and poor rural areas, especially those which have suffered from manufacturing collapse.


Even these statistics about the opioid epidemic and its impact are don't tell the whole depressing story.   Many of the premature deaths among those addicted come from infectious diseases related to needle use - and these are not likely to be counted in the graphic above.   I blogged about a disheartening New Republic story in 2014 entitled "Public Health and Health Care Financing Choices Made AIDS an American Disease."

Opioid addiction is terrible - it changes the brain - and simply invoking willpower won't possibly be enough to help most addicts.   The criminalization of drug abuse has led addicts to share needles - with deadly results.  The US is alone among developed countries to be reluctant to provide needle exchange -  despite overwhelming evidence that this can decrease transmission of HIV and hepatitis and other blood borne diseases.

The Washington Post published an important article about drug abuse earlier this week   The hot spots for opioid addictions (which are mostly in deep red Appalachia and the midwest) are pretty much exactly where needle exchanges are least likely to be located.  This is good reason why we need an effective, evidence-based national approach to public health challenges like IV drug abuse.