Tampilkan postingan dengan label narrative. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label narrative. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 03 Maret 2017

Obamacare stories to turn the tide

Timmy Morrison, featured in story by Sarah Kliff on vox.com 


There are a lot of damning numbers about the evolving Republican plan to undo the Affordable Care Act.  32 million are likely to lose their insurance;   52 million Americans have  preexisting conditions; the top 0.1% of the population would get an average tax break of $197,000 from repeal of the ACA.

But I think the Obamacare debate will ultimate turn on stories-- because of the "availability heuristic." We make decisions based not on statistics -but based on the stories with powerful narrative force that remain top of mind. 

Sarah Kliff, a vox.com reporter who previously worked at the Washington Post's Wonkblog, has written many of the most compelling stories.

Kliffidentified a 5 year old with a rare genetic disease who was born just after the ACA. His care exceeded lifetime maximums in his first few months of life.   Without the ACA, his family would have declared bankruptcy -and it's not at all clear how they would have afforded his ongoing care. His photograph is at the top of this post.

Sarah Kliff also interviewed many Kentucky Trump voters  who had voted for Donald Trump- even some whose job was to do ACA enrollments.  Try not to feel awful when you read about this woman whose husband is on the liver transplant list.  This really is a matter of life and death.   Her quote:

I don't know. I guess I thought that, you know, he would not do this. That they would not do this, would not take the insurance away. Knowing that it's affecting so many people’s lives. I mean, what are you to do then if you cannot … purchase, cannot pay for the insurance?

I am still struck by reporting that Kliff did in 2012 about a graduate student in Texas who was doing bake sales for his chemotherapy - because he had hit the pre-ACA lifetime maximum.

The New York Times has also had good reporting on what potential ACA repeal means to real people.  In the interest of balance, the Times report also included some people who feel harmed by the ACA - like those whose premiums went up.  They often had higher premiums for better coverage, but didn't end up using this additional coverage so resented the cost, or even opted out of the system due to cost.

Some of the quotes:
“I Would Have Had to Decide Between Food and a Doctor Visit”
“I’m absolutely terrified”
“We Have No Other Means to Get Affordable Health Care”
National Public Radiohas also been reporting on the real world implications of ACA repeal.  

From a West Virginia mom whose 29 year old son suffers from opiod addiction (and who will lose services if the ACA is repealed:

"It's kind of like you're on a parallel track with them," she says. "You wait for the next crisis; you wait for the next phone call. You're upset when you don't get a phone call. You're just — you're desperate, and you're in a state of fear and anxiety so much of the time."

A coal miner with black lung disease who could lose his insurance if the ACA is repealed:

"You try to get air in them, and they don't want to cooperate with you as they did before," says retired miner James Bounds, speaking with great effort. Not every coal miner gets black lung, just as some smokers don't get cancer. But for those who do, Bounds says, the disease is devastating.

A widow in North Carolina who lost her insurance when her husband died:

Hawes, 55, is from Charlotte, N.C. She ended up going without insurance for a few years, but in 2015 she bought coverage on HealthCare.gov, the Affordable Care Act marketplace, with the help of a big subsidy.
"I was born with heart trouble and I also had, in 2003, open-heart surgery," she says. "I had breast-cancer surgery. I have a lot of medical conditions, so I needed insurance badly."

Stories matter.  I'm grateful we have a free press that shares facts and impactful anecdotes!

Rabu, 14 Desember 2016

We need powerful stories to drive public opinion


There is No Managing Health Care Costs Number Today


There’s a battle raging – a battle between statistics – lovingly subject to regression and other analyses -- and stories – raw and full of emotions.

I like statistics – especially when done well.  The flag bearers for using statistics to determine public policy are gifted economists Kate Baicker of the Harvard School of Public Health and Amy Finkelstein of MIT.  They have helped us learn the real impact of Medicaid expansion through their studies of the Oregon natural experiment to randomly give Medicaid to some but not other equally needy residents.   We’ve learned a lot about the value of Medicaid to real people from Baicker and Finkelstein – we should certainly  use this knowledge when we are crafting public policy.

Baicker and Finkelstein recently wrote in Health Affairs blog:

Policies are not enacted in the abstract; they affect real people’s lives, and we should all be concerned with how policy changes help or harm them. Unfortunately, as moving as those stories can be, they can just as easily lead us in the wrong direction as the right one. What we need is evidence, not anecdote.
…
Personal narratives can yield vital insight into how policies affect people’s lives, humanizing the stories behind the numbers and suggesting important areas for further research. Dismissing these compelling stories as “mere anecdotes” in favor of more rigorous—but impersonal—data analysis can seem heartless. But making policy based on unrepresentative anecdotes can inflict much greater harm on many more people. We hope that use of rigorous evidence will become the norm rather than the exception in health policy.

While policy should be driven by evidence, we won’t be able to gather support for evidence-based policy based on the research alone.

I guess I’d have to say that powerful stories, many of them transparently false, have also driven our political discourse over the last year.  (John Podesta and the pizza shop child pornography ring in DC? Really? )   It’s even more distressing to hear that many of these stories were planted by Russian spies under the guidance of the Kremlin.   

I’ve been looking at charts like this – that show how many of the working poor were left behind  in states that did not expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act.   Full Medicaid expansion would have brought almost 15 million more into the world of health insurance.  But that number is just a number. And Kaiser Family Foundation has been producing these charts for 5 years already and Medicaid has expanded a bit - but there are still 19 states which have retained the "gap" that leaves many ineligible for either Medicaid OR ACA subsidies 


Yes you read this graph right.  Only one of these states EVER provides Medicaid to nondisabled nonparents, and  TX and Alabama require an income of under 18% of the federal poverty limit for parents with kids to qualify.  100% FPL is $20,160 for a family of three- so a mom with two children would need to make less than $4000 a year to qualify for Medicaid in Alaabama and Texas.   Really. 

Last week, the New York Times magazine published “Life in the Obamacare’s Dead Zone,” deeply personal stories of mostly women in the Midwest who are irreparably harmed because their states have not expanded Medicaid.   Janet Foy could not afford the sliding scale $35 therapist visits to control her depression.  Suzan Emmons earned enough in Kansas to get federal assistance to purchase an exchange plan. When she took custody of her granddaughters who faced abuse at home, her income dropped into the “gap” and her subsidies were yanked away.   Shanette Smith’s dreams of becoming a nurse were shattered  when she was unable to matriculate at school because she couldn’t show proof of insurance. 


By the way , “dead zone” gives more of a sense of what’s really going on here than “gap.”  As we’ve learned from Republican strategist Frank Luntz, words matter.

So – today’s managing health care costs number will return, and I’ll still be eager for the kind of insightful research done by Baicker and Finkelstein and so many others.  I hope we build our policy on that strong foundation. 

But we’ll need to tell a lot of intimate, personal, and powerful stories to gain the support for making access to health care a right in this country, as we enter this new scary era.