Tampilkan postingan dengan label mortality. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label mortality. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 30 Juni 2017

Air pollution kills even at low doses



Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  7.3%

  

Yesterday's New England Journal of Medicine lead article demonstrates that fine particulate matter and ozone exposure cause excess death even at levels that are less than current guidelines - even as the Trump Administration seeks to eliminate current regulations associated with the Clean Air Act which have helped make our air dramatically cleaner than it was a few decades ago.   

The study design is elegant - using virtually all Medicare beneficiaries from 2000-2012 (over 60 million), associating them with residential zip codes, and then associating those zip codes with levels of fine particulate matter and ozone and then correlating with mortality.   The main analysis suggested an increased mortality risk of 7.3% for each 10 ยตg of fine particulate matter.  They then analyzed this a number of ways (see above) - and each analysis showed a striking relationship that remained linear even well under what is considered acceptable under current regulations. 


The findings suggest there may be no threshold of fine particulate matter or ozone that is safe  - and that efforts to further reduce air pollution from current levels can save many thousands of lives.

Accompanying editorialists remind us that we learned that smog kills in 1946, when 26 people died of a smog episode in Pennsylvania:

In late October 1948, a dense smog descended over the town of Donora, Pennsylvania. The town was home to a zinc plant and a steel mill, both run by the United States Steel Corporation. Susan Gnora, a 62-year-old resident of Donora, started to gasp and cough as the smog descended.  She died the next day. Dr. William Rongaus, a physician and a member of the board of health, went door to door, treating patients for their respiratory symptoms and encouraging them to leave town if they could. Many thousands were ill, and at least 20 people died in one of the worst air-pollution disasters in U.S. history. The Donora tragedy transformed our perception of smog from a nuisance to a potential killer.




 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For the weekend, two other health policy  must reads from Vox.com

Julia Belluz shows how California has dramatically reduced maternal mortality

Researchers from Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health show the calculations demonstrating that the Better Care Reconciliation Act could cost 228,000 lives over the next decade

Kamis, 22 Juni 2017

Expanded health care coverage improves and saves lives

Expanded health care coverage improves and saves lives

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 23 million

Offering millions of people access to meaningful health insurance is expensive - and many conservatives have said that our country simply cannot afford expanded access.  They propose to cut a trillion dollars from health care assistance for low and moderate income individuals to finance a trillion dollar tax cut aimed at the wealthy.   Periodically, they suggest that there is no evidence that offering people access to health insurance improves lives, outcomes, or mortality.

Ben Sommers, Atul Gawande, and Kate Baicker have published a timely and thoroughly researched literature review (on line today from the New England Journal of Medicine without a paywall).   Perhaps some Senators or their staffers will have the time to read this powerful article since there is still no Senate Republican health care bill to review as of this morning.

They found that expanded access to coverage leads to:

  • Fewer medical bills sent to collection
  • More use of outpatient visits and more use of and adherence to medications
  • More evidence-based preventive care and screening
  • Better care for chronic disease
  • Earlier diagnoses of curable cancers
  • Increase in likelihood of reporting good or excellent health
  • A trend toward decreased  mortality (although not reaching statistical significance)


They conclude:

An analysis of mortality changes after Medicaid expansion suggests that expanding Medicaid saves lives at a societal cost of $327,000 to $867,000 per life saved.By comparison, other public policies that reduce mortality have been found to average $7.6 million per life saved, suggesting that expanding health insurance is a more cost-effective investment than many others we currently make in areas such as workplace safety and environmental protections. Factoring in enhanced well-being, mental health, and other outcomes would only further improve the cost–benefit ratio.

We would not be having a public debate about taking away health care access for the rich or the well-connected.   We should be debating  how to finance universal access.  That's a debate we had in 2009 - out in the open with dozens of hearings and hundreds of amendments.  It's not the debate we are having now over the American Health Care Act.  We also should  be talking seriously about how to lower the cost of health care  - as opposed to how to lower the number of Americans who have access to health care. 

Increasing health care coverage improves lives and health.   Ripping coverage away is bound to do the opposite.  Republican Senators representing states like West Virginia, Ohio, Kentucky Alaska and Louisiana owe it to their constituents to refuse to support legislation that will lead to premature and preventable deaths in their communities. 

Selasa, 13 Juni 2017

Tiered networks save $; Teaching hospitals can save your life

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 1.5%

Exchange plans have gravitated to narrow networks - and many have been encouraged that narrow networks allow higher value while being an important element of leverage with provider systems that have excellent reputations, high market leverage and command premium pricing.  Most of these high-leverage systems are anchored by academic medical centers (AMCs).  AMCs have higher costs than non-teaching hospitals because:

  • They do teaching - which increases costs as trainees order extra tests or are less efficient
  • They offer highly specialized services which have low volume
  • They take care of the sickest of the sick - and even risk adjustment probably doesn't fully reflect the real resource costs of the care they provide.

Nonetheless, it's been hard to show any correlation between this higher cost and better quality or better outcomes -and narrow networks that restrict access to the highest priced systems have proliferated, and have seemed like a good idea.

Employer plans have followed - narrow networks are frankly much more attractive than additional cost shifting to members who already face substantially more out of pocket spending than they did a few years ago.

The Commonwealth Fund showed that in Massachusetts tiered networks were associated with 5% lower costs - with no apparent loss of quality.  In Massachusetts, though, academic medical centers deliver an outsized portion of total care, and few narrow networks exclude all major teaching hospitals.

Lower metallic level plans across the country are increasingly offering no access to AMCs.  This could be a challenge for people who have severe illnesses where AMCs are required.  Presumably these plan do pay for AMC care for patients who need liver transplants or the most specialized of care -- but patients and their physicians need to jump through difficult hoops that are a special challenge to patients and their families confronting catastrophic illness.

JAMApublished research late last month that represents a challenge to narrow networks.   Researchers reviewed over  21 million Medicare admissions from 2012-2014 to major teaching hospitals (6%), minor teaching hospitals (20%), and nonteaching hospitals (74%).  They found:

Unadjusted 30-day mortality was 8.1% at major teaching hospitals, 9.2% at minor teaching hospitals, and 9.6% at nonteaching hospitals, with a 1.5% (95% CI, 1.3%-1.7%; P<.001) mortality difference between major teaching hospitals and nonteaching hospitals.

The difference persisted after risk adjustment - and was true regardless of the size of the hospital.  (Austin Frakt, one of the researchers, summarized this in the NYTimes Upshot).

Ouch.  This research looks solid.  The sample size is huge (100% of the Medicare database).   The mortality difference isn't from more aggressive diagnosis coding - and the differences are statistically significant in 13 of 15 top DRGs and 5 of 6 surgical categories.  

This is Medicare data - the difference might not be applicable to the population under 65.  Differences among hospitals within each category might still be more important than the difference between teaching hospitals and nonteaching hospitals.  But I think this research poses a serious challenge to the effort, which I've vigorously supported, to move "community" medical care away from the major teaching hospitals.

I believe that adult inpatient care will eventually follow pediatric inpatient care.  Very little inpatient pediatric care is done in non-teaching hospitals at this point.  If kids are sick enough to be in the hospital they are in a teaching hospital - otherwise they are cared for at home.  Many of the conditions that required multiple day hospitalizations when I was in training are now treated on an ambulatory basis.  That trend will continue.

But in the meantime, these researchers have shown us a caution flag in the effort to move inpatient care away from the most expensive inpatient providers.  This will make efforts to control unit prices even more important.




Senin, 08 Mei 2017

Nine TrumpCare Lies

Nine TrumpCare Lies


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 9


The Republicans hit the talk shows and the radio waves this weekend to defend the indefensible American Health Care Act (AHCA).  There are lies everywhere - making the moniker "TrumpCare" totally appropriate.  Here are five key recurrent lies:

Lie One: At least the AHCA will lower the cost of health care. 
No such luck. There is nothing in the bill that would lower the cost of actually delivering health care; at least the ACA had alternative payment models  and the CMS innovation center and pathway for approval of bioequivalent drugs.  The CBO estimatesthat the premiums will actually increase by 15-20% by 2019.  Premiums will be lower in 2026 not because costs have been averted, but because sick people will be priced out of the market. 

Lie Two:  The AHCA will have no impact on employer-sponsored health insurance .
Au contraire.  Employer mandate will be eliminated, and employers will be able to  base their benefits on a benchmark plan that from a state that has opted out of essential benefits and doesn't require coverage of preexisting conditions or  prohibit annual and lifetime maximums. Further, those covered by employer sponsored health insurance will be more reluctant to leave their jobs (whether to start a new business or retire early) since the individual market will be back to its dysfunctional pre-Obamacare state, where only healthy people qualify for insurance.  Most employers will not want to go back to the pre-ACA policies - but the most vulnerable are those in low skill low wage industries where workers most need the protection they will likely lose.

Lie Three: No states will opt out of the ACA essential benefits and preexisting condition rules anyway.
Bullsh#t.   Tom Reed, a New York representative, said this on NPR on Saturday.  If no states would opt out, there'd be no reason to include this clause in the legislation.  Look at the 19 states that have harmed their residents by not expanding Medicaid.  States will be lobbied hard by various business interests to eliminate these requirements - and all it takes is a single state to opt out to mean that self-insured plans across the country can eliminate this required coverage. 

Lie Four:  We are not going to kick people off Medicaid!
Really? Then where is that $880 billion of savings coming from?  Remember that the majority of Medicaid spending is on the elderly and dual-eligibles (those with disabilities) - and it's hard to kick grandma out of a nursing home. The impact on Medicaid for poor people is likely to be far worse.  "Grandfathering" current Medicaid beneficiaries isn't so helpful when 1/3 cycle in and out of Medicaid eligibility each year.   Don't forget - Medicaid covers about half of all births in the US!

Lie Five: High risk pools will protect those with preexisting illnesses

High risk pools are invariably subject to "death spiral" where they are so expensive that all but the sickest decide not to sign up - making them  even more expensive in subsequent years.  The only way to make high risk pools work is with massive public subsidies, and there is widespread agreement that the AHCA offers too little.   Representative Fred Upton's $8 billion in additional funds (over 3 years) is not nearly enough.  

Lie Six: No one dies because they don't have access to health care.

Raul Labrador (R, Idaho) was roundly booed when he asserted this at a town hall this weekend.  Researchers suggest somewhere between 24,000 and 48,000 a year would die because of the "old" AHCA -before it was made worse by the new amendments

Lie Seven: The Senate will never pass this intemperate and ill-considered bill.

One thing we've learned in the past year is that we can't count on traditional political wisdom.  The White House cares about wins, and promotes the AHCA as a distraction from other issues  including Russia, environmental degradation, and corruption.  Anyone who thinks the Senate could never pass such a destructive bill should reconsider- and remember that the eventual Senate bill will be compared to the AHCA, not to optimal health care policy that maximizes coverage and value purchased.  The House moderates would never have voted for the AHCA. And then, after a few cosmetic billion in funding for high risk pools, they fell into line.

Lie Eight: The Obamacare exchanges are failing.

There are problems with the exchanges - and most of these are generated by decisions made by state regulators (which allowed sales of non-exchange products that skim off the healthy) or by Congress (which removed risk corridor funding) or the Trump Administration (which has signaled it won't enforce the individual mandate and is daring the insurers to abandon the market by failing to commit to cost sharing reduction payments required by law).

Lie Nine:
This is all about health care policy.

Not really.   The AHCA is a tax cut of close to a trillion dollars that will almost all go to the most wealthy.  Those with income of over $1m will on average gain a $50,000 tax cut; those   The Republicans desperately want to deliver that tax cut - and will tolerate almost immeasurable damage to the health care system to do it.  

Senin, 20 Maret 2017

Death Panel of 535 -how many the AHCA will kill


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 24,000

Via Flickr creative commons license 

As the scheduled House of Representatives vote on the American Health Care Act is only 3 days away, and as Paul Ryan continues to tweak the legislation to satisfy conservatives (who want deeper cuts in Medicaid) and moderates (who want to make the bill less dreadful for those over 50), it’s worth looking back at research that shows how much insurance matters.

The AHCA if passed is expected to lead to an excess of between 24,000 and 48,000 deaths per year.

Julia Belluz did a  review of the work of Ben Sommers and others about a week ago on Vox.com – reprising work she did a month earlier. Giving people insurance decreases mortality.   

A New England Journal 2012 study said that 20 lives were saved annually per 100,000 who were newly enrolled in Medicaid. A 2014 study in Annals of Internal Medicine showed that health care reform in Massachusetts decreased mortality by 2.9% in the state compared to a control state that did not do health care reform in 2006 –a decrease in mortality of 8 per 100,000 insured.  

New research published in the Annals of Internal Medicineshows that cystic fibrosis patients live 10 years longer in Canada than in the United States.   Those with insurance in the US have life expectancy similar to CF sufferers north of our border.  Mortality is dramatically higher in those who are uninsured.

Median age of survival in patients with cystic fibrosis increased in both countries between 1990 and 2013; however, in 1995 and 2005, survival in Canada increased at a faster rate than in the United States (P < 0.001). On the basis of contemporary data from 2009 to 2013, the median age of survival in Canada was 10 years greater than in the United States (50.9 vs. 40.6 years, respectively). The adjusted risk for death was 34% lower in Canada than the United States (hazard ratio, 0.66 [95% CI, 0.54 to 0.81]). A greater proportion of patients in Canada received transplants (10.3% vs. 6.5%, respectively [standardized difference, 13.7]). Differences in survival between U.S. and Canadian patients varied according to U.S. patients' insurance status.

It seems like a pretty terrible time to kick 24 million people off insurance!  Of course, you don't need to read medical journals to know that!

Throughout the 2009 debate on the Affordable Care Act, there were false claims that the ACA included "death panels."  The real death panel, it turns out, is the members of the US House and Senate.  Let's hope they make the right decision. 

Rabu, 15 Februari 2017

Deaths from failure to expand Medicaid


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 3163



Source of Medicaid expansion eligibles: Kaiser Family Foundation
Source of mortality savings from insurance expansion: Annals of Internal Medicine

Note Wisconsin provided benefits to those with income up to 133% of FPL prior to ACA, and data on eligibility from Maine is not available

A policy decision made by 19 state governments might lead to more deaths each year than the number of Americans who died at the World Trade Center, in the Pentagon, and in the cornfield in rural Pennsylvania during the 9-11 terrorist attacks.  

Harvard researchers looking at the experience of Massachusetts’ health care reform estimate one prevented death for every 830 who gain insurance.    But 864,000 Texans, 467,000 Floridians, and 309,000 Georgians are not covered by the Affordable Care Act’s Medicaid expansion since the Supreme Court gave states the ability to opt out.  This research suggests that expanding Medicaid coverage to the 2.6 million who would be eligible in states that have  resisted Medicaid expansion could save 3163 lives each year.  (Note that the numbers in the bar chart above add up to less than this due to rounding).

2997 people died in the 9-11 terrorist attacks.

Failure to expand Medicaid is a special problem because those under 133% of the Federal Poverty Level are ineligible for subsidies to purchase health insurance on the ACA exchanges.   Many states that did not expand Medicaid offer no chance for those without young children to qualify for Medicaid; in a few states, the threshold for even young parents to qualify for Medicaid is 18% of the FPL – or $3600 annual income for a family of 3!

Expanding Medicaid is also incredibly inexpensive. The federal government pays 90-100% of the cost of expansion – and some calculations suggest that state tax collection alone could fully fund the state portion of the bill.   Medicaid pays low provider rates – and the average cost of Medicaid expansion has been $2700*.  So even the federal investment to provide this additional coverage would be pretty modest too.

This is just a projection – and the Massachusetts research is not necessarily totally applicable to other states.   Researchers considered all expansion (not just Medicaid), and medical care in Massachusetts was readily available to the newly covered; that might not be true in some rural areas.  On the other hand, Sommers’ research showed that improvement in mortality in Massachusetts was highest where the pre-reform uninsured rate was higher and where income was lower. This sounds like the populations in many of the nonexpansion states, so this projection might be too  low.

Perhaps failure to expand Medicaid hasn’t cost 10,000 lives since 2014.   But it’s hard to argue that lives have not been lost by the short-sighted decision not to expand Medicaid.
*Calculation of cost of adults and children:
Total on Medicaid: 68 million  (3/4, or 51 million, are adults and kids)
Total Medicaid Cost: $397.6 billion.  (36%, or $140 billion, spent on adults and kids)
$140b/51m enrollees ~=$2700 per enrollee

Selasa, 20 Desember 2016

Hospital Quality (and Mortality!) Varies Widely


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 3:1



The New York Times reported this weekend that “Go to the wrong hospital and you’re three times more likely to die.”  Scary!  The Plos One research this was drawn from had a more sedate headline: “Quantifying Geographic Variation in Health Care Outcomes in The United States before and after Risk Adjustment.” 

We know that health care quality is variable, and we know that the correlation between quality and cost is, uh, not especially robust.  This research drew on data from 22 million hospital admissions – both Medicare and  younger privately insured patients. –and used 16 different data sources to assess mortality from multiple different disease processes.

Researchers assessed mortalityfor 6 conditions (heart attack, heart failure, stroke, gastrointestinal bleeding, hip fracture and pneumonia) – and counted avoidable complications (pressure ulcers, punctured lungs, central line infections, postop hip fractures and blood clots and infections and wound failure rates, and lacerations) and preventable hospital admissions (diabetes, lung disease, heart failure, dehydration, pneumonia, urinary infection, asthma and diabetic amputation).


The researchers show the hospital and county level of performance (10th % and 90th%ile) – and the differences are startling.  Here is the data for heart attack:




Unadjusted hospital level mortality is four times higher at the hospital level at the worst hospital compared to the best – although this difference is diminished when the data is adjusted for demographics (pop) and comorbidities and hospital case volume (system). 

But we all would agree that a 2.3 times higher mortality for a heart attack is pretty terrible – so the Times headline is justified –and we should be worried and take action. 

But taking action on this data will not be easy.

  • The researchers were not allowed to reveal the names of different hospitals – so no one can use this database to figure out what hospital to avoid when you’re getting a hip replacement, or having a heart attack.  
  • The data is from 2011- and performance at many hospitals has likely changed in the last 6 years.
  • There is VERY little correlation in results across these different diagnoses (see the grid below).  Hospitals with better outcomes for heart attacks  were no more likely than chance to be better at mortality for congestive heart failure –although hospital performance in the mortality metrics other than heart attacks were weakly correlated.  There was pretty much no correlation between mortality and safety or prevention indicators – which makes it hard to know what the best performing hospitals are doing compared to poorly performing hospitals.
  • This is a single year of data –and we’d need to see that these results were stable over time – and not just the result of randomness. 
  • We simply can’t send 100% of patients to the top ten percentile of hospitals – there wouldn’t be enough room, and their performance would likely fall.
  • Wide geographic variation means that for many Americans, there are no “best” hospitals to seek out without hopping on a plane – hard to do when you are having an acute heart attack!


This research is an important wake up call.   We need more such longitudinal research.  We should provide incentives for patients to get their care at high value facilities, and we should provide social cues (and incentives) for poorly performing hospitals to do better. 

We also need to move to making data from these efforts publicly available.  It can be built into transparency and navigation tools – and some patients will move to higher value facilities. Most importantly, the facilities that have higher mortality or complication rates or are less effective at prevention would be shamed into improving their performance.

All graphics or data from Plos One article . This graphic shows that outside of the IQIs (excepting heart attack) there is little correlation of hospital performance among different measures.  So finding a hospital with a good score on pneumonia care (IQI 20) does not mean that hospital is likely to be good at preventing pneumonia admissions (PQI11), or have a low rate of accidental lung collapse (PSI06). 

-->

Selasa, 06 September 2016

Good news about heart disease and cancer deaths


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 43%






Health  care costs too much – and it’s defective.    A simple office visit can cost $300 – and the doctor stares at a computer.  A delivery costs $20,000, and there’s a 1 in 3 chance the obstetrician will perform a Cesarean Section –and around half of these could be avoided.  EpiPen costs $600, and pharma-bro Martin Shkreli increased the price of Daraprim from $13.50 to $750 a pill.    

Further, a substantial portion of the feel good news stories about new research turn out to be early reports – which are often not borne out by further research .   Few news stories give a full reference to the original research, and many are downright misleading.

I’ve been working 2016-17 academic syllabi over the weekend – and I found these two charts in a Commonwealth Foundation report from last fall comparing health care across multiple countries.      This shows that the likelihood of dying of heart disease in the US has dropped by 43% from 1994 to 2013 -and the likelihood of dying of cancer has dropped by 17% from 1995 to 2007   (These figures are age adjusted – which is only fair, since the ultimate mortality rate of humans remains 100%).

So- we have every right to complain about the expensive, impersonal, and downright wasteful care that we get.  Much of the improvement in heart disease mortality didn’t come from the medical world (like statins for cholesterol and angioplasties for heart attacks), but came from the public health world (the dramatic decline in the use of tobacco products). The same could be said for cancer deaths.  We should be skeptical about news reports about the latest cure for cancer.

Still – there is a lot less premature death from heart disease and cancer – and the medical system and the pharmas have had something to do with this.  Let’s celebrate.