Tampilkan postingan dengan label essential benefits. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label essential benefits. Tampilkan semua postingan

Senin, 08 Mei 2017

Nine TrumpCare Lies

Nine TrumpCare Lies


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 9


The Republicans hit the talk shows and the radio waves this weekend to defend the indefensible American Health Care Act (AHCA).  There are lies everywhere - making the moniker "TrumpCare" totally appropriate.  Here are five key recurrent lies:

Lie One: At least the AHCA will lower the cost of health care. 
No such luck. There is nothing in the bill that would lower the cost of actually delivering health care; at least the ACA had alternative payment models  and the CMS innovation center and pathway for approval of bioequivalent drugs.  The CBO estimatesthat the premiums will actually increase by 15-20% by 2019.  Premiums will be lower in 2026 not because costs have been averted, but because sick people will be priced out of the market. 

Lie Two:  The AHCA will have no impact on employer-sponsored health insurance .
Au contraire.  Employer mandate will be eliminated, and employers will be able to  base their benefits on a benchmark plan that from a state that has opted out of essential benefits and doesn't require coverage of preexisting conditions or  prohibit annual and lifetime maximums. Further, those covered by employer sponsored health insurance will be more reluctant to leave their jobs (whether to start a new business or retire early) since the individual market will be back to its dysfunctional pre-Obamacare state, where only healthy people qualify for insurance.  Most employers will not want to go back to the pre-ACA policies - but the most vulnerable are those in low skill low wage industries where workers most need the protection they will likely lose.

Lie Three: No states will opt out of the ACA essential benefits and preexisting condition rules anyway.
Bullsh#t.   Tom Reed, a New York representative, said this on NPR on Saturday.  If no states would opt out, there'd be no reason to include this clause in the legislation.  Look at the 19 states that have harmed their residents by not expanding Medicaid.  States will be lobbied hard by various business interests to eliminate these requirements - and all it takes is a single state to opt out to mean that self-insured plans across the country can eliminate this required coverage. 

Lie Four:  We are not going to kick people off Medicaid!
Really? Then where is that $880 billion of savings coming from?  Remember that the majority of Medicaid spending is on the elderly and dual-eligibles (those with disabilities) - and it's hard to kick grandma out of a nursing home. The impact on Medicaid for poor people is likely to be far worse.  "Grandfathering" current Medicaid beneficiaries isn't so helpful when 1/3 cycle in and out of Medicaid eligibility each year.   Don't forget - Medicaid covers about half of all births in the US!

Lie Five: High risk pools will protect those with preexisting illnesses

High risk pools are invariably subject to "death spiral" where they are so expensive that all but the sickest decide not to sign up - making them  even more expensive in subsequent years.  The only way to make high risk pools work is with massive public subsidies, and there is widespread agreement that the AHCA offers too little.   Representative Fred Upton's $8 billion in additional funds (over 3 years) is not nearly enough.  

Lie Six: No one dies because they don't have access to health care.

Raul Labrador (R, Idaho) was roundly booed when he asserted this at a town hall this weekend.  Researchers suggest somewhere between 24,000 and 48,000 a year would die because of the "old" AHCA -before it was made worse by the new amendments

Lie Seven: The Senate will never pass this intemperate and ill-considered bill.

One thing we've learned in the past year is that we can't count on traditional political wisdom.  The White House cares about wins, and promotes the AHCA as a distraction from other issues  including Russia, environmental degradation, and corruption.  Anyone who thinks the Senate could never pass such a destructive bill should reconsider- and remember that the eventual Senate bill will be compared to the AHCA, not to optimal health care policy that maximizes coverage and value purchased.  The House moderates would never have voted for the AHCA. And then, after a few cosmetic billion in funding for high risk pools, they fell into line.

Lie Eight: The Obamacare exchanges are failing.

There are problems with the exchanges - and most of these are generated by decisions made by state regulators (which allowed sales of non-exchange products that skim off the healthy) or by Congress (which removed risk corridor funding) or the Trump Administration (which has signaled it won't enforce the individual mandate and is daring the insurers to abandon the market by failing to commit to cost sharing reduction payments required by law).

Lie Nine:
This is all about health care policy.

Not really.   The AHCA is a tax cut of close to a trillion dollars that will almost all go to the most wealthy.  Those with income of over $1m will on average gain a $50,000 tax cut; those   The Republicans desperately want to deliver that tax cut - and will tolerate almost immeasurable damage to the health care system to do it.  

Jumat, 21 April 2017

 Could we have a death panel for TrumpCare?

Could we have a death panel for TrumpCare?


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 217


Dylan Scott of Vox calls this Vampire TrumpCare – because attempts to revive the reviled American Health Care Act continue to proliferate – and the bad ideas embodied in this bill just can’t seem to be killed.

1)      The Freedom Caucus of hard-line right-wing Republicans and the Tuesday Group of self-styled moderate Republicans have been debating options to allow states to opt out of the insurance reforms of the ACA as long as they have high risk plans where disadvantaged sick people can seek refuge.   But these high risk plans are always under-funded – so many will be unable to afford the premiums.   Bad idea.

2)     Ted Cruz inveighs against the unaffordable mandates and essential benefits.   But the most controversial – free contraception – actually lowers the cost of health care.  And do we really want health plans that don’t cover maternity care, or mental health. Yup – I’m a guy in my 50s and I won’t personally be using a maternity benefit again.   But I don’t want young moms and families bankrupted by the cost of delivering a baby!  We already have the least friendly environment for young families (no mandatory maternity and paternity leave, for instance).   Do we want to make this worse?  Julie Rovner has a nice summary today in Kaiser Health News showing that the cost of these mandatory benefits is not what’s breaking the bank. Rovner also points out that doing away with standardization of insurance will make it impossible to have risk sharing for high cost members across plans.

3)      States should have choice.    Sounds good in theory – and I don’t want to have Oklahoma deciding health care policy in Massachusetts.  The New York Times has a review of how two states with Republican governors, New Mexico and Oklahoma, had vastly different approaches to Medicaid expansion and exchanges.  In New Mexico the uninsured rate plummeted, there is brisk competition of insurers on the exchanges, and premium increases have been modest.  In Oklahoma – Obamacare is a disaster.  The Supreme Court designed a great natural experiment about what happens when states have the ability to decide not to implement federal health care policy.  Just look at the disparity among states in Medicaid expansion to see how well that worked!
 
4)      All Republican repeal plans erase the individual mandate.  Fine – no one wants to be told what to do.  But getting the healthy to purchase insurance is critical to having sustainable insurance markets.  Insurers won’t sell insurance at reasonable prices if people only purchase that insurance when they are already sick, much as you can’t purchase home insurance when  your house is burning down.  Many dislike the individual mandate philosophically – but have offered no great alternative. Regina Herzlinger, a conservative, pro-market Harvard Business School professor, has a review in JAMA of how Switzerland, Germany and Singapore achieve universal coverage without turning to a single payer . The answer in two words: Individual Mandate. The answer in a paragraph:

Switzerland, Singapore, and Germany have achieved universal coverage and made insurance affordable even for their citizens with highest health care costs by instituting an individual mandate. One major difference, however, is that unlik   e the ACA, the mandates instituted by these countries are reinforced with effective penalties for nonparticipation, thus ensuring that lower-cost enrollees—generally healthier individuals—balance out the costs of the others who require more medical resources.

Trump has set another deadline for voting on TrumpCare: Wednesday 4/27.   The bill continues to be a collection of bad ideas that have already been disproven in the market.   Sarah Kliff points out that the barriers to passing this poorly designed legislation are Yuge.  They need 217 votes – let’s hope they continue to fall short. 

Rabu, 23 November 2016

Essential benefits prevent risk selection


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 10

It would be loopy to eliminate essential benefits 

There’s been a lot of talk about “essential benefits” in the Affordable Care Act.  These benefits are required of all health plans - not just those health plans in the Obamacare exchanges.  Mandated benefits are a double-edged sword. They make sure that certain services are covered, and that people are not duped into buying health plans that would provide them with little coverage if they get sick. They mandate coverage for preventive services that otherwise might be underused.  BUT mandates make premiums more expensive. First dollar coverage of certain essential services decreases consumer price sensitivity, and mandated coverage likely means that deductibles and cost sharing for other services goes up. 

The essential health benefits  mandated by the ACA are:

    • Outpatient care (like doctor’s office visits)
    • Emergency room visits
    • Inpatient care
    • Maternity and newborn care
    • Mental health and substance abuse care
    • Prescription drugs
    • Rehabilitation services
    • Laboratory services
    • Preventive services
    • Pediatric services


These are not especially controversial - no one thinks that a health plan that excludes emergency room services is “real” health insurance.   Before the Affordable Care Act, 2/3 of health plans sold on the individual markets excluded maternity care.  That allowed those not expecting to have a baby to pay lower rates -but it made coverage that included maternity care prohibitively expensive.

The essential benefits are actually an important effort to decrease risk selection. Since all health plans must cover these essential benefits - no health plans will suffer from recruiting patients who are “shopping” for services they know they will need.   Eliminating the essential benefits would allow health plans to “innovate” in health plan design, but it’s likely that most innovation would be seeking positive risk selection.

Many states have mandates for health plans to cover what they judge to be essential services -but the Employee Retirement and Income Security Act (ERISA, 1973) exempts employer-sponsored self-insured plans from these state mandates.  The Affordable Care Act was an important national effort to be sure that Americans had access to meaningful coverage and health plans were not using plan design to attract positive risk. 

Some object to the requirement that health plans cover birth control, as it is an essential preventive service for women.  Note that birth control is one of the few medical services that is cost saving, so that eliminating this requirement would make health plans more expensive.  Further, long acting reversible contraception has helped dramatically decrease the abortion rate in the US. Still, many object to this requirement.  I suspect few of those objecting are women of childbearing age. 

The ACA allows reasonable cost sharing for non-preventive services, and allows health plans to limit coverage for essential services to in-plan providers.  If i had my druthers I’d do away with the cost -free “annual wellness exam,” which is wasteful.  And I might allow some cost sharing for preventive services - but these are minor quibbles. 

But essential services should be covered by all health plans, and eliminating these coverage requirements would be bad public policy.