Tampilkan postingan dengan label concentration of cost. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label concentration of cost. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 06 Juli 2017

TrumpCare: Defective insurance plans to fleece policyholders




Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  49.5%


As Kim Jung Un fires ballistic missiles into the waters off Japan and Donald Trump encourages the right wing in Poland, the Senate continues to work under the cover of heavy secrecy on a bill to strip health care from tens of millions. 

But that's not enough.   In the name of free markets, Ted Cruz has suggested that insurance companies should be allowed to sell insurance plans that do not comply with pre-existing condition prohibitions or offer all ACA-required essential benefits  - as long as in each state they offer at least one plan that does comply with ACA requirements. 

Here's how this would work.   Insurers would offer one plan that complied with the Affordable Care Act.  This plan would  cover maternity (just think!), mental health services, ambulance rides, prescription drugs, and emergency rooms. (All of these requirements would be waived in the non-compliant plans).   The plan would be available for the same price to all comers, whether they were healthy or had preexisting illnesses.  The plan would be attractive to those at high risk - so it would have to have a high price.  It would also likely be saddled with the largest allowable deductibles and coinsurance - to discourage utilization and to keep the premium from being even higher.   

This plan is the definition of a "death spiral."  Insurers would offer compliant plans to gain the right to offer the less inclusive plans, which would be priced to sell.   Risk for having babies or taking expensive medicines would be transferred to individuals - as healthy members would no longer be subsidizing the sick.    Those with preexisting illnesses could choose between affording their housing or their health insurance. 

What would noncompliant insurance look like for those at low risk who could make it through the underwriting process to gain eligibility?  For starters, it would be cheap!   Five percent of the population represents49.5% of all medical costs - so you could design an insurance plan for 40% less if you could exclude those expensive patients - and still make a whopping profit.  But Mitch McConnell will focus on the lower prices, not he value of the available plans.     

However that noncompliant plan would be a bum deal.   It could be a "mini-med" plan which had a cap of a few thousand dollars - enough for an emergency room visit.  (These were banned by the ACA - but would be revived under Trumpcare).   It would exclude specialty medications which often cost $100,000 a year, and would not cover mental health services.  It would be designed to be unattractive to those with real needs -because that's how to make such a plan profitable.  Do you need maternity care?  Then buy a rider priced at the cost of delivery!


These plans would have very low "medical loss ratios."   Under the ACA, insurers must issue refunds if their administrative costs exceed 15-20%.   Those rebates would go away - and insurance company profitability would soar.   That's why health plans are ambivalent about TrumpCare.  They hate going back to offering plans designed to exclude coverage for the sick - but those profits are mighty attractive.

Even worse, the bottom 50% of the population represents under 3% of total costs.   Imagine how cheap the health plan catering to just the healthiest half of the population could be - while leaving room for healthy profits. 
  
We don't allow automakers to sell cars without bumpers.  We don't allow furniture makers to sell baby cribs that have risk of finger amputation or decapitation.  The government has a role in promoting public safety -and this role includes structuring markets to prevent the sale of defective or dangerous goods.  

There's no reason to allow the resurrection of insurance plans that fleece  policyholders and leave sick people with no coverage.  The Senate should reject this terrible idea.

Senin, 29 Agustus 2016

Out of pocket costs soar and the middle class reels



Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $2679



Friday’s Wall Street Journal highlighted research published by Kaiser Family Foundation and Brookings Institute  earlier this year.   The WSJ noted that out of pocket expenses are going up – hitting the middle class especially hard.  

David Cutler, a Harvard health-care economist, said this may be “a story of three Americas.” One group, the rich, can afford health care easily. The poor can access public assistance. But for lower middle- to middle-income Americans, “the income struggles and the health-care struggles together are a really potent issue,” he said.


Source
Diane Schantzenbach of Brookings shows the “crowd out” impact of the high cost of health care (and housing). This has led to fewer dollars being available for other uses, including food clothing and transportation.   The researchers don’t quantify impact on savings for education and retirement, or vacation expenses.

The WSJ article also quoted the April KFF research by Gary Claxon and coauthors that showed the dramatic increase in deductibles and conversion from copayments to coinsurance.  This has profound impact on patients- it means that those who obtain the most expensive care pay a higher amount out of pocket – and it creates enough uncertainty about how much patients will owe that it discourages use of care that appears to patients to be discretionary. 

This move has also changed the compact of social insurance.   There is now less subsidy of those with higher costs than there was in the past – meaning that employer-sponsored health insurance is less likely to shield families with substantial illness from financial ruin than in the past.   I’ve displayed the 2004 and the 2015 KFF data graphically; this how much more out of pocket costs are borne by those at the top 15% of cost. 



This fails to demonstrate is how much higher still the out of pocket costs are for those in the top 5% of costs (who represent 49% of all costs)., or those in the top 1% of costs (who themselves represent 21% of all costs.    Out of pocket maximums provide some protection, but these are increasingly calculated across the entire family – leaving families with a “bronze” style plan often responsible for at $12,000 or more in annual costs.