Tampilkan postingan dengan label World Economic Forum. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label World Economic Forum. Tampilkan semua postingan

Senin, 23 Januari 2017

Reflections on Davos

Here are a few reflections on my week at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland.  I note that there is rich irony in the well-off intelligentsia gathering at an exclusive (and expensive) Swiss resort town to mull problems like income inequality and refugees and war.  For business folks, Davos is a way of efficiently meeting clients and potential clients.  For policy-makers, it's a good place to have a debate with someone you might disagree with. There are too few places where people who disagree have a conversation, so in that sense Davos is meeting a most important need.

The Trump administration stated agenda is antithetical to the precepts of the World Economic Forum, which is committed to the expansion of free trade, more open borders, more international cooperation and action on climate change. Still, there were many attendees who are looking forward to the potential impact of Trump's promises on their businesses:
  • Many businesses, especially agriculture, petrochemical, and developers, hate government regulation - and they are counting the regulations they want to see gutted
  • The pharmaceutical industry is hopeful that rhetoric about controlling costs will give way to enthusiasm about decreasing barriers to new (and likely expensive) drugs.   From a value perspective many new drugs are of marginal incremental value, so this bodes ill for controlling health care costs.  (Here's one press account)
  • I listened to some financial service industry folks decry Dodd Frank- and look forward to a lighter regulatory hand of government. 

I learned a lot this week about "The Future of Work."  My Willis  Towers Watson colleague, Ravin Jesuthasan, has written booksand articleson this topic.  The general idea is that artificial intelligence (AI) and automation are likely to make many current white collar jobs obsolete - and this will cause the same kind of social disruption that the loss of manufacturing jobs has caused in the US.   This won't just affect lawyers and accountants - even software coding is better done by machines (they are fast and make no mistakes once the humans have established the underlying goals and rules).  We know that some of the work that physicians do can be made easier with AI - so this could even come to medicine.

This isn't the terrible dystopian outcome that "robots are taking over the world."  This move toward more automation should lead to a dramatic increase in productivity, and should free humans to be more creative. But how will we distribute this productivity?    If all of this goes to shareholders, inequality will get worse, and the angry populist wave that is spreading across the globe could get far worse. 

Many predict that workers will move from having jobs to having "gigs."   This will allow people to have more of a diverse portfolio of work -- but the current social safety net and the way we provide benefits and retirement to US residents doesn't support this very well at all.

There is a lot of talk at Davos about Basic Income - which would provide a certain amount of noncontingent income for all- with no strings attached. Many studies show that the poor will use this money reasonably wisely, and this should not diminish entrepreneurship since there is no penalty to making more money.  Even Paul Ryan has suggested he could support basic income.  Here's a good read on the topic from Vox,  Of course many want to add more requirements to programs for the poor.

Some interesting sessions I attended:
  • An AARP- Foreign Policy Journal session on keeping people in the productive workforce as they age.  Michael Rothkopf,editor-in-chief of Foreign Policy, introduced the concept of "Gross Knowledge Product," and Jo Ann Jenkins, the CEO of AARP, noted that 50% of babies born this year will live to 104.  Employers in the US should economically be even more avid for earlier retirements given that their self-insurance plans pay
  • Communicating on health with the underserved -- I was surprised that social media ranked lower in impact than health plan web sites - and I'm a bit dubious.  In any event, there's no question that we need better ways to communicate health care with everyone. I'm most encouraged by research on community health workers - they have been key to acceptance of HIV testing and treatment in South Africa, and hiring community health workers is a "two-fer" in that it gives members of the local disadvantaged communities good jobs while making communication more culturally relevant.
  • Putting individual health data in an electronic lockbox so that only those patients can give anyone permission to access that for research purposes.  The data from claims and electronic medical records could be married with data from mobile phones, which will make it more valuable than having large de-identified databases . The deidentified data can never be merged with other data sources because of the deidentification.   I'm skeptical.  I think there will be huge selection issues regarding who will give permission to use their data, and the friction of requiring this step will substantially delay research.   It's certainly interesting technology though.  (midata.coop)
  • A NY Times reporter wrote about attending as a spouse with his wife who is (literally) a clown in Lebanon who does humanitarian work in refugee camps.  She talked briefly at one of the sessions I attended, and told a moving story of time passing and growing hopelessness in those refugee camps.
  • Gender discrimination:  The Female Quotient  offered a series of seminars - eBay has achieved 100% gender pay equity - but it is an outlier.  Women continue to be underrepresented among engineers. Although some predict more future success with the "female way" of having more empathy and treating all with more respect (unlike classic male hierarchy), all the speakers recounted being advised not to "treat the admins with such respect' and to avoid showing emotions at work. 

The confluence of people from many walks of life at Davos also means I got to talk to participants about many subjects outside of health care, with potential implications in health care.

  • The future of construction - Apparently China assembled a 57 story earthquake resistant skyscraper with almost entirely prefabricated elements last year.   3D printing in construction is finding its way as well; a pedestrian bridge in Amsterdam is using the technology now.   Some medical device solutions are the equivalent of prefabrication- and hopefully we'll be printing organs some day.
  • I talked to the CEO of a foundation seeking to accredit orphanages, which currently house over 8 million kids.   The best answer is always for kids not to be put in orphanages, but there are good evidence-based approaches that lead to far less emotional damage.   This foundation raises money to help fund the transition to a more home-like environment.
  • I talked to a Swiss entrepreneur who develops agricultural chemicals and does all the efficacy and safety testing before selling or licensing these to the agro-chemical companies. He describes the importance of "derisking;"  established companies are looking to purchase "sure things."   Much like the Pharma industry.
  • There was a lot of talk in Davos about the Indian government's recent ban on all large currency bills - which should dramatically decrease economic friction (AND bribery and tax evasion).   I heard amazing stories of those with black market money hurriedly converting this to goods (sometimes with plans to return those goods for digital currency).   Toll booths also were apparently stripped of their small bills, too.  Because many Indian industries were largely in the 'informal' market and the pure cash economy , though, this move has meant that many businesses found themselves unable to sell goods for a number of months.  This will likely lead to a decrease in GDP in India this year.  The lesson to medicine- think carefully about implications of major system changes!

Back to the usual "managing health care costs" topics over the next few days!

Senin, 16 Januari 2017

Greetings from Davos


I am in Davos, Switzerland,  at the World Economic Forum this week.  I've been part of a Willis Towers Watson team working on using behavioral economic precepts to decrease risk factors for non-communicable disease (NCD), and will be giving a talk and moderating a panel discussion on this topic on Thursday.

A few factoids about NCDs: Source
  • NCDs cost about 1.7 trillion disability adjusted life years annually
  • About 80% of all NCD deaths occur in low and middle income countries
  • 6 million deaths annually can be attributed to tobacco smoking. Note that the death toll from hypertension is 7.5 million deaths, and obesity causes 2.8 million deaths a year while physical inactivity is responsible for 3.2 million deaths a year.   (Many deaths have multiple risk factors - so these are attributed fractionally to the different causes.)

Disability adjusted life years (DALYs) are a good way to look at the total burden of disease, which helps describe the economic toll of NCDs.  DALYs are like quality adjusted life years-  but are focused on an equivalency of high quality life-years LOST, while QALYs (Quality Adjusted Life Years) are focused on years of high quality life gained. DALYs also include time discounting which QALYs do not.   Early iterations of DALYs gave preference to life years of young adults saved, although more recent calculations do not.

My colleague Michael Dean input data from the World Health Organization and the Institute for Health Metrics into an interactive data visualization (using Tableau).  

Here are publicly available data visualizations I'll be using at a presentation at the World Economic Forum in Davos this week. 

Data Visualization 1 shows the impact in disability adjusted life years of noncommunicable diseases by country: 

Data Visualization 2  shows how this has changed in the last quarter century. Note the increase in DALYs in less developed countries is especially high. 

Here is a brief YouTube video describing use of this data visualization tool

I expect to do some additional blogging from the World Economic Forum this week. 

From a WEF/WTW white paper.  CRD is chronic respiratory disease