Tampilkan postingan dengan label Sarah Kliff. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Sarah Kliff. Tampilkan semua postingan

Rabu, 13 September 2017

Dueling visions of health care policy

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 30 million


Two competing health plans have been in the news today. Bernie Sanders has rolled out his "Medicare for All" plan, and the Lindsey Graham Bill Cassidy proposal has gained new "moderate" support and will be yet another Republican attempt to repeal Obamacare.

First, the Republican plan.   David Leonhart titled his post on this "New TrumpCare Deserves a Quick Death." He points out that although the sponsors claim that this bill would allow states freedom to innovate - it would rapidly decrease the available funds.  Even states committed to universal health care access might be hacking away at the number of those with subsidized insurance very quickly.  The Congressional Budget Office hasn't weighed in yet -but this bill is close enough to past TrumpCare bills that he estimates it would lead to 15 million additional uninsured in 2018, and 30 million losing insurance over the next decade.

It's hard to say that Graham-Cassidy absolutely won'tpass, and it would be a deeply disruptive bill that would make health care in the US much worse than it currently is.  The more time Congress spends on that bill, the less effort it will put into the market fixes we so desperately need for the Affordable Care Act.

With great fanfare, Bernie Sanders has introduced his Medicare for All plan today.   He has 17 cosponsors in the Senate (he had none when he introduced his last universal health care bill), and about 60% of House Democrats have endorsed a different universal health care bill.   The Sanders approach is aspirational - In an interview with Vox, he says:

I mean, this is a big issue, and we are introducing comprehensive legislation at a time when we have Donald Trump as president, who wanted to throw 32 million people off the health insurance. You know, Mitch McConnell, Paul Ryan, running the Senate and the House. We're not going to get this thing done with these guys in power.

Sarah Kliff has a summary of the details of the Sander's plan.   The initial plan was explicit about benefits and cost sharing (rich benefits for all, no substantial cost sharing for patients) and mum on costs; this afternoon he released additional details including a 7.5% employer payroll tax exempting small businesses (that's much less than most employers spend on health coverage), and a 4% income tax on individuals exempting low income people. For many, this would be a good deal.

And that's the problem.   If Sanders is able to provide insurance for all with close to no cost sharing (which means there will be more discretionary utilization), it's either going to cost more (much more, as California discovered) or providers will be paid much less.  The Sanders plan would create a national fee schedule (Medicare), but would increase payment to providers caring for Medicaid beneficiaries.   The decline in provider reimbursement would have to be huge to provide enough savings to make this work.

We need meaningful reform of the health care system - and we need lower unit prices.  There will be plenty of time to evaluate whether the Sanders plan is the best way to get to universal access - and I'm in favor of modest cost sharing as opposed to no cost sharing at all.  Today lets us all see the vision of each party -- one is satisfied to leave 30 million additional Americans uninsured; the other wants to insure everyone, but there is a danger that this is the "unicorn" plan in that it is rooted in fiction in that it might not be affordable.




Jumat, 08 September 2017

 Trump efforts to keep heathy people out of the exchanges

Trump efforts to keep heathy people out of the exchanges


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  90%


We want those with serious illness to have health insurance as a matter of public policy and basic human decency. We don’t want US residents dying on the hospital steps, and we don't want people to have bake sales to pay for their chemotherapy.  We also don't want hospitals going bankrupt caring for those without insurance, and we don't want individuals losing their homes to liens placed by hospitals for emergency care delivered.

We also want healthy people, those least likely to "need" insurance, to have health insurance.  If only the sick have insurance, premiums would go through the roof.    If most healthy people opted out of health insurance, the insurance market would shrivel and die, as those with the least needs dropped out each successive cycle. That's the essence of the dreaded "death spiral."

The Trump administration announced this week that it would cut advertising for the Affordable Care Act exchange plans by 90% for this open enrollment period.   Having failed to repeal the law, they are seeking to fulfill their predictions of the ACA imploding by starving the exchanges of their lifeblood- the relatively healthy.

There's been good reporting in the New York Times and Vox about the other efforts the Trump Administration has made to decrease the likelihood that healthy people would sign up for insurance through exchanges this next cycle.

  • The New York Times reports that CMS removed "helpful links on its website on the day of Trumps inauguration, including summaries of benefits, emergency services, and doctor choice, making it more difficult for consumers to learn about the law."
  • CMS announced a 40% cut in navigators to do Obamacare outreach.   Sarah Kliff of Vox reports today that the navigator cut is worse still.  The navigator nonprofits have received no funds at all -and have been told that no grants will be retroactive so that staff must be laid off now. Perhaps they will still be available to be rehired for the November 1 open enrollment.  Perhaps not.
  • HHS is spending some of the marketing dollars not attracting healthy people into the ACA markets, but rather attacking the law.  The New York Times notes that CMS produced dozens of YouTube videos and infographics with strident anti-ACA messages.
  • The IRS announced it would accept tax returns with no notations in the query about health care coverage, telegraphing a lack of interest in collecting the individual mandate penalty, which is largely aimed at being sure to encourage healthy low-cost people to join or remain in the plan
  • The monthly threat to withhold Cost Sharing Reduction payments has led many health plans to price their premiums assuming the CSRs will go away - making health insurance less affordable - especially for those who get little or no government subsidy


It's no secret that the Trump Administration is filled with those who want to eliminate the Affordable Care Act.  They failed legislatively - and they have shifted their effort to strangulation of the ACA exchanges.   Efforts to deprive the exchange plans of the healthy members they need for financial viability could still make ACA plans unavailable for millions, and unaffordable due to adverse selection for millions more.  In some instances, their efforts could persuade more insurers to exit the market - which will lead to more "bare counties," lost subsidies, and millions more uninsured.  

These executive actions aren't subject to Congressional Budget Office study- so we won't see headlines about their impact.  But they will certainly lead to a higher percentage of Americans uninsured in 2018. 

Selasa, 01 Agustus 2017

 Maybe a bipartisan health plan is possible?

Maybe a bipartisan health plan is possible?


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 5
 

John McCain rose to the occasion last week and cast one of 51 deciding votes against the ill-named Health Care Freedom Act, aka skinny repeal, which would have led to loss of health coverage for 16 million Americans.    The "repeal and replace Obamacare" movement has been declared dead, although yesterday President Trump tweeted continued threats to blow up the exchanges by not continuing Cost Sharing Reduction payments, and even threatened to stop paying the employer portion of health care premiums for Congressmen and their staffers.  So the effort to repeal is not dead.

A bipartisan group of 40 moderate Republicans and Democrats in the House has just offered ` to increase stability of the individual markets and lower health care costs.  This was first reported on Politico on Sunday.  I'm not confident that Paul Ryan would ever bring this bill up for debate - and if he did, it's not clear there are enough votes to pass it.  But there are some good ideas here.  The five pillars of this legislation

  1. Fund the Cost Sharing Reductions.  They are necessary for exchange policies to be useful for those with low incomes (but over 133% of the federal poverty level), to be sure that their out of pocket costs for care don't make their ACA plans useless.  The dollars in the federal budget are small, and it's likely that health plans would raise premiums (which the feds are also on the hook to pay) -so the winners here will be those with over 400% of FPL income who get insurance on the exchange without subsidies.  This will be hard for Republicans to swallow - it increases federal expenditures.
     
  2. Create a dedicated stability fund for the states.  This could be used to create reinsurance so that health plans didn't have to worry so much about enrolling the sickest of the sick - which would be an important complement for "guarantee issue."  Like funding CSRs, this would be a big Republican give.
     
  3. Exempt employers with 51-499 employees from the employer mandate.   No employer has paid employer mandate penalties so far as this mandate has been delayed, and most employers would intend to continue employer coverage regardless.  This could lead to some losing insurance, though - so it will be a bitter pill for Democrats committed to universal coverage.
     
  4. Repeal of medical device tax.  This tax has also been delayed - it would have raised $20 billion over 10 years.   It's not critical to the success of the Affordable Care Act or the individual exchanges.  Congressmen and women on both sides of the aisle would be fine with this.
     
  5. Promote sale of health plans across state lines.   This is already live in a number of states, and the health plans have expressed no interest.   States with more rigorous regulation of their health care insurance markets will continue to oppose federal preemption of their regulation, and further fragmentation of the health plan markets could lead to higher prices.   States will also worry rightly that a state far away won't be as vigorous in insuring health plan financial stability.  Democrats won't like this - especially since the regulations will be written by the Trump Administration. But getting CSRs and a reinsurance type fund might be worth the dangers this could cause.  Here's an older KFF brief on the subject, and a recent Sarah Kliff review (see item (4))

So - perhaps my estimation of the potential for a bipartisan approach was needlessly pessimistic.   The Republicans might not share the Democratic commitment to universal coverage, but they are not willing to wrench coverage away from millions.  The Democrats know they are in the minority - and appear willing to accept some painful compromises.

Again - it's not clear that the House will act on this proposal - but it's heartening to see some bipartisan efforts to improve health care take root.

Jumat, 14 Juli 2017

Compromise is hard when there is no agreement about goals

Compromise is hard when there is no agreement about goals


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 4
 

The new revised  Republican Senate health care bill is worse than the last iteration of the Better Care Reconciliation Act.
 
  • It will still cause devastating cuts in Medicaid - an incredibly valuable program that finances delivery for 45% of deliveries, 60% of nursing home stays and a substantial portion of the costs of substance abuse treatment.  
  • It is worse in that it allows insurance plans to sell non-compliant health plans - and allows the healthy to use health savings accounts or federal subsidies to purchase these skimpy plans.  That will lead to even more of the young and healthy skipping out of comprehensive health plans -and price more of the old and sick out of the market
  • It adds a little to subsidies for the near-poor - but not enough for most of them to be able to purchase health insurance that has affordable premiums and out of pocket costs that are income-appropriate
  • It puts an inadequate amount into high risk pool funding - and distributes this to the states, which historically have failed at setting up effective high cost pools
  • It puts some dollars into opioid programs, but decimating the Medicaid program will offset the good that comes from this.
  • It would allow many Americans to be in health plans that would not cover essential benefits - so that the funding for those benefits would be threatened for those who need them.
  • Separate Republican bills would prohibit the IRS from enforcing the individual mandate, which would further erode the health of those in the exchange and lead to higher prices and potential "death spiral."

A group of Democratic House members have put forward their plan to "fix" Obamacare.   This bill is thoughtful and would represent a real step forward.   It includes

  • Commitment to paying the cost sharing reductions going forward
  • Higher amount of subsidies to attract the healthy to the exchange markets, with aggressive marketing and potentially changing the open enrollment cycle to tax refund season
  • Enforcement and potential increase in the individual mandate penalties
  • Permanent reinsurance fund to protect health plans from the costs of enrolling the highest risk members
  • An ill-defined mechanism to allow older pre-65 Americans to "buy into" Medicare, which would also help take some of the most expensive patients off the individual exchange markets.

What's striking about these two efforts is that there is essentially no overlap. The Republicans seek to decrease taxes (on the rich) and decrease the role of the government in both financing and regulating health care, even though the US health care system is a failed experiment in leaving the system to only a very lightly regulated market in the eyes of many economists.  The Democrats want to insure affordable access to health care for all - and are willing to do this by increasing the role of government - even though all those with current levers of power adamantly oppose this and are ideologically and politically committed to moving in the opposite direction.  

It's really hard to compromise when there is no overlap in what each party is looking for!

I've been thinking hard about where there could be room for compromise, and frankly, I don't see much.   A few preliminary thoughts:

Concept
Party Positions
Challenge
Decrease regulations that prevent less expensive practitioners from providing services
Republicans are often against regulations - and these are regulations that genuinely could increase market effectiveness
The doctor, dentist, and even nurse lobbies are adamantly opposed and claim that these regulations protect consumers.
 
Further, these are largely state regulations, and federal preemption of state regulation is fraught with problems
Increase enforcement of antitrust laws, as provider consolidation is a major reason for unit cost increases
Democrats in general are more supportive of antitrust enforcement; Republicans are more likely to worry about government interference
Providers have a huge amount of political influence, and oppose such enforcement
Offer national reinsurance  at a low attachment point, so that the care beyond $50 or $75,000 annually would be the responsibility of the federal government
Republicans are putting tens of billions into high risk pools -although they would likely be loathe to use these funds for a federal program.  
 
Democrats have proposed this before (Kerry 2004 health care plan).

This could also help decrease risk selection in health plans, and would be a relief to employers who struggle with high cost cases. 
Insurance companies (and reinsurers) would not necessarily like losing this portion of their current business.

Ideally the federal government would have the states administer this through their existing Medicaid non-managed care contracts, and could fund this 100% to avoid state rejection
Increase funding for anti-fraud efforts
These pay for themselves, and no one is in favor of fraud and abuse!
Some will again worry of government overreach, and the Trump Administration is in the process of disassembling regulatory apparatus.

Some of the more extravagant claims of fraud include simple coding errors (like a woman being miscoded as a male and then a delivery being considered "fraud").

There is a ceiling of potential savings - though we are nowhere close to that yet.
 




That's all I've got. Just four rows.   It's not much to work off of - and none of these are slam-dunks.  This highlights just how hard it will be to develop a compromise in these polarized times.

Kamis, 15 Juni 2017

Wresting health insurance from 23 million without a single hearing

Wresting health insurance from 23 million without a single hearing



Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  Zero


Under cover of a metastasizing Russia scandal, news the Special Counsel is investigating the President for obstruction of justice, and the heinous gun attack on the Republican congressional baseball team practice, you'd almost never know that the Senate is poised to put the final nails in the coffin of ObamaCare. 

There have been articles - and good ones - describing Mitch McConnell's strategy to pass a bill ("any bill") without telling the public anything about the bill.  These include reporting by Sarah Kliff, Julie Rovner, an op ed by David Leonhardt.

Leonhardt also pointed out that the parties you'd think would be advocating tirelessly against the American Health Care Act, including the American Hospital Association, are strangely quiet.  The AHA just asked the Trump Administration to scuttle the Medicare Stars program (rating hospital quality) and not require future meaningful use of electronic medical records.  Perhaps there is a quid pro quo?

The New York Times posted an article about the secrecy of the Senate health care bill this afternoon.  The authors recount the not-secret-at-all origins of the Affordable Care Act:

The Senate health committee approved its version in July 2009 after considering hundreds of amendments over 13 days. The Senate Finance Committee cleared its version in October 2009, after more than a year of hearings, round-table discussions and other spadework. A group of Democrats and Republicans from the Finance Committee met for months behind closed doors, trying — but ultimately failing — to draft bipartisan legislation.

The full Senate passed the Affordable Care Act on Dec. 24, 2009, on the 25th consecutive day of floor debate.


Health care represents over 1/6 of the US economy. A party that got 3 million fewer votes in the Presidential election and lost House and Senate seats in the 2016 election is about to take health insurance away from 23 million people without a single hearing and without a Congressional Budget Office score.  

It's easy to be deeply distressed.

Senin, 01 Mei 2017

 Republican Congressman crafts amendment so others can share experience of brutal medical bills

Republican Congressman crafts amendment so others can share experience of brutal medical bills


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $1 million


Here are the first three paragraphs of an Associated Press article from earlier today:

New Jersey Rep. Tom MacArthur has experienced personal tragedy and understands the need for health insurance.

"I lost my mother at 4 years old. My father had no insurance and I watched him until I was in college pay off medical bills," says the two-term Republican lawmaker.

Years later, MacArthur suffered the anguish over the death of his 11-year-old daughter, Gracie. "We had over $1 million of medical bills. I had insurance, but I still had a lot of uncovered expenses, and it's brutal," he says.

Ironically, MacArthur has just proposed an amendment to the already outrageous American Health Care Act which would allow states to eliminate Affordable Care Act essential benefits and preexisting illness requirements as long as the state says that premiums will come down and it establishes a high risk pool for those who are denied insurance. 

This has been tried before – the high risk pools are always underfunded, and the premiums are so high that only those with the highest costs enroll.   So health insurance premiums come down for the healthy – and health insurance is unavailable practically for the sick.

The real story is that MacArthur has learned nothing from his family’s tragedies.

Sarah Kliff just published a profile of a single mom with three children who lost her home and savings due to medical bills before ObamaCare – and who lives in a county in Tennessee that has no insurers committed to exchange plans in 2018.   She’s weaning herself off health care, and telling her children what to do if she suddenly dies.  


Selasa, 07 Maret 2017

The American Health Care Act debut

(C) cmfu via Flickr Creative Common License 
Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 0

We're 24 hours out from the unveiling of the American Health Care Act (AHCA), the Republican bill seeking to end Obamacare as we know it.   The zero above is how much analysis has been completed by the Congressional Budget Office. Nonetheless, Committee hearings start tomorrow.

The House Energy and Commerce Committee  has put out a summary document, and there are good summaries available from:

This bill is substantially less conservative than the leaked draft of a few weeks ago.  Specifically

  • The tax credits to fund exchange plans for the poor and near poor are refundable (so they can be obtained even by those who pay no federal income tax)
  • Rich people will not be eligible for these tax credits, meaning the amount available for the poor and near poor is higher.  The credits start phasing out at income of $75,000 (individual) and $150,000 (family)
  • Medicaid expansion will remain relatively untouched until 2020
  • Essential benefits will remain a requirement
  • The employer sponsored health insurance tax deduction has not been changed

Still, the plan remains deeply regressive and likely to hurt public health and lead to more uninsured and worse health outcomes.

  • The amount of tax credit offered will not be adequate for the poor and near poor to afford premiums
  • The Cost Sharing Reduction (CSR) for those earning less than 250% of the federal poverty limit (FPL) is gone as of 2020 - meaning that those of very modest incomes won't be shielded from high deductible health plans. 
  • Would change Medicaid to a per capita grant to states as of 2020
  • Offers huge tax savings to the rich through eliminating most taxes associated with the ACA in 2018, even though the programs continue unchanged until 2020. That will blow a huge hole in the deficit.
  • The amount of relief available for middle income Americans goes up a bit, and for poor Americans goes down a lot.
  • The AHCA eliminates public health funding (12% of the CDC budget)
  • Lowers the eligibility for children from 133% to 100% of the FPL
  • Removes federal funding for state expansions of Medicaid to above 133% of FPL as of 2019
  • The age band increases from 3:1 to 5:1 - so young (healthy) people could shave a few hundred dollars from their premium, but older Americans who are more likely to suffer from a serious illness will have to pay more.   Even if the bill does not decrease the number insured, it could decrease the number of high risk people insured
  • There is plenty of language about requiring proof of citizenship for Medicaid coverage, and rechecking eligibility every 6 months.  Medicaid rolls could shrink just because of hassles, which are harder for the poor to overcome.
  • Required actuarial values will go away, making it harder for consumers to shop
  • The AHCA seeks to eliminate all Medicaid coverage for any service obtained at a Planned Parenthood office. Plan Parenthood is the largest provider of women's health services in the country. 

There's plenty of reporting about the basic details of the plan - which is not as bad as I expected but still likely to cause an enormous amount of pain and harm.  Here are two of the more arcane elements, which have not yet been fully reported on.


Section 113 – Elimination of DSH Cuts
Repeals the Medicaid Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) cuts for non-expansion States in
2018. States that expanded Medicaid would have their DSH cuts repealed in 2020.

This is a surprise. Safety net hospitals have been devastated by the loss of DSH funds in states that did not expand Medicaid.  This could be a lifeline for them.

Section 114 (b)
• Would limit the effective date for retroactive coverage of Medicaid benefits to the
month in which the applicant applied. This provision would apply to Medicaid
applications made (or deemed to be made) on or after October 1, 2017.

This is awful for the sick who are poor - and also poison for hospitals.  It often takes weeks or months to prove eligibility, and now only future medical expenses will be covered.

There are also some open questions.

Bob Kocher and others have tweeted that mental health parity is gone.  I can't find this in the bill - or in any coverage.   MHPAEA (Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act) was separate legislation passed in 2008, although the ACA included some additional enforcement

Republicans have been angry about some efforts to reform provider payment - and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation has been threatened. It appears to have escaped the axe in the AHCA


It is difficult to say what question, or set of questions, would lead to this bill as an answer. Were voters clamoring for a bill that cut taxes on the rich, raised premiums on the old, and cut subsidies for the poor? Will Americans be happy when 15 million people lose their health insurance and many of those remaining face higher deductibles?


Jumat, 03 Maret 2017

Obamacare stories to turn the tide

Timmy Morrison, featured in story by Sarah Kliff on vox.com 


There are a lot of damning numbers about the evolving Republican plan to undo the Affordable Care Act.  32 million are likely to lose their insurance;   52 million Americans have  preexisting conditions; the top 0.1% of the population would get an average tax break of $197,000 from repeal of the ACA.

But I think the Obamacare debate will ultimate turn on stories-- because of the "availability heuristic." We make decisions based not on statistics -but based on the stories with powerful narrative force that remain top of mind. 

Sarah Kliff, a vox.com reporter who previously worked at the Washington Post's Wonkblog, has written many of the most compelling stories.

Kliffidentified a 5 year old with a rare genetic disease who was born just after the ACA. His care exceeded lifetime maximums in his first few months of life.   Without the ACA, his family would have declared bankruptcy -and it's not at all clear how they would have afforded his ongoing care. His photograph is at the top of this post.

Sarah Kliff also interviewed many Kentucky Trump voters  who had voted for Donald Trump- even some whose job was to do ACA enrollments.  Try not to feel awful when you read about this woman whose husband is on the liver transplant list.  This really is a matter of life and death.   Her quote:

I don't know. I guess I thought that, you know, he would not do this. That they would not do this, would not take the insurance away. Knowing that it's affecting so many people’s lives. I mean, what are you to do then if you cannot … purchase, cannot pay for the insurance?

I am still struck by reporting that Kliff did in 2012 about a graduate student in Texas who was doing bake sales for his chemotherapy - because he had hit the pre-ACA lifetime maximum.

The New York Times has also had good reporting on what potential ACA repeal means to real people.  In the interest of balance, the Times report also included some people who feel harmed by the ACA - like those whose premiums went up.  They often had higher premiums for better coverage, but didn't end up using this additional coverage so resented the cost, or even opted out of the system due to cost.

Some of the quotes:
“I Would Have Had to Decide Between Food and a Doctor Visit”
“I’m absolutely terrified”
“We Have No Other Means to Get Affordable Health Care”
National Public Radiohas also been reporting on the real world implications of ACA repeal.  

From a West Virginia mom whose 29 year old son suffers from opiod addiction (and who will lose services if the ACA is repealed:

"It's kind of like you're on a parallel track with them," she says. "You wait for the next crisis; you wait for the next phone call. You're upset when you don't get a phone call. You're just — you're desperate, and you're in a state of fear and anxiety so much of the time."

A coal miner with black lung disease who could lose his insurance if the ACA is repealed:

"You try to get air in them, and they don't want to cooperate with you as they did before," says retired miner James Bounds, speaking with great effort. Not every coal miner gets black lung, just as some smokers don't get cancer. But for those who do, Bounds says, the disease is devastating.

A widow in North Carolina who lost her insurance when her husband died:

Hawes, 55, is from Charlotte, N.C. She ended up going without insurance for a few years, but in 2015 she bought coverage on HealthCare.gov, the Affordable Care Act marketplace, with the help of a big subsidy.
"I was born with heart trouble and I also had, in 2003, open-heart surgery," she says. "I had breast-cancer surgery. I have a lot of medical conditions, so I needed insurance badly."

Stories matter.  I'm grateful we have a free press that shares facts and impactful anecdotes!

Rabu, 04 Januari 2017

Repealing Obamacare = Reverse Robin Hood


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 15


Run, right away, to view Sarah Kliff’s 15 charts explaining the Affordable Care Act and the Republican attempt to repeal it.  

All of Kliff’s charts are simple and spare and tell an important story –one of an unprecedented increase in number of Americans with health insurance, and general satisfaction with the results of the ACA with persistent hatred of the law itself, especially among Republicans.

Some ACA proponents are happy today because Kellyanne Conway, Trump’s advisor, said in an interview that “if you like your insurance, you can keep it.”  Jonathan Chait wrote that “Republican efforts to repeal Obamacare may be collapsing.”  Ezra Klein  wrote “One of Trumps advisors just made repealing Obamacare much, much harder.”


But before you feel any better about the chances that we’ll suffer from a collapse of the exchanges and a dramatic pullback in Medicaid funding, here’s the chart you have to see – from the Tax Policy Center.  The Affordable Care Act profoundly redistributed (helping counterbalance our growing economic inequality) by imposing large taxes on the wealthiest 1%, and giving large tax subsidies to those in the bottom two income quintiles. 

Repeal of the ACA would be a boon for the rich – decreasing taxes for the top1% by $33,000, and for the top 0.1% by $197,000.   This makes me far less confident that the tax subsidies for exchange plan purchase and Medicaid enrollment are really safe from the new Administration and its congressional allies.  For all the talk of working class people and fiscal discipline, repealing Obamacare represents a giveaway to the rich and an increase in our national deficit.

====
This suggests that if you like your health insurance and it's provided by your employer you can keep it 

-->

Senin, 10 Oktober 2016

  Health Care Discussed in Second Presidential Debate

Health Care Discussed in Second Presidential Debate


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 1756


Not many can say that they got their wish out of the second presidential debate – Trump threatened to misuse the judicial system to prosecute his opponent, and the lewd 2005 videotape released on Friday hung over the entire affair.  BUT – there was some real talk about health care!

Early on, Trump pointed to the failure of ObamaCare

….horrible things like Obamacare, where your health insurance and health care is going up by numbers that are astronomical, 68 percent, 59 percent, 71 percent…

Not exactly.  Premium rises will average 9% - still far too high – and the increased premiums for those who are eligible for subsidies are lower.

An audience member asked the question:

Premiums have gone up. Deductibles have gone up. Copays have gone up. Prescriptions have gone up. And the coverage has gone down. What will you do to bring the cost down and make coverage better?

Clinton noted 20 million additional Americans have insurance, the elimination of lifetime limits and denial of coverage based on existing illness, coverage of those under 26 on their parents’ policy, and elimination of higher premiums for women.

Trump suggested repeal and replacement by “something less expensive,” although the ACA has cost far less than as initially predicted.  (h/t to Sarah Kliff who did real time fact checking on health care). He focused on eliminating “state lines” in health insurance, ignoring substantial evidence that allowing sale of policies across state lines is unattractive to health insurers and would be unlikely to substantially lower costs – which are driven by provider costs in each community.  Entrance of a new insurance company from out of state with no leverage to get lower rates would be no help –and could cause additional purchaser fragmentation and higher total costs. The states now regulate health plans to be sure they are financially sound – and the boosters of cross-state insurance sales have not articulated a plan to establish national regulation to replace this.  Trump also alleged that Canadians were flooding across the border to get American medical care – which is patently untrue.  He also accused Clinton of supporting single payer – which would be a real surprise to Bernie Sanders supporters from the Democratic primary.

Anderson Cooper asked Clinton about her husband’s  statement that ObamaCare is “the craziest thing in the world.”   She responded

Look, we are in a situation in our country where if we were to start all over again, we might come up with a different system. But we have an employer-based system. That’s where the vast majority of people get their health care.

And the Affordable Care Act was meant to try to fill the gap between people who were too poor and couldn’t put together any resources to afford health care, namely people on Medicaid. Obviously, Medicare, which is a single-payer system, which takes care of our elderly and does a great job doing it, by the way, and then all of the people who were employed, but people who were working but didn’t have the money to afford insurance and didn’t have anybody, an employer or anybody else, to help them.

That was the slot that the Obamacare approach was to take. And like I say, 20 million people now have health insurance. So if we just rip it up and throw it away, what Donald’s not telling you is we just turn it back to the insurance companies the way it used to be, and that means the insurance companies …get to do pretty much whatever they want, including saying, look, I’m sorry, you’ve got diabetes, you had cancer, your child has asthma… you may not be able to have insurance because you can’t afford it. So let’s fix what’s broken about it, but let’s not throw it away and give it all back to the insurance companies  

Cooper pressed Trump about whether he would mandate health coverage – which is critical to convincing the healthy to be in the insurance pool.   He again cited restrictions on selling health insurance across state lines, and added block granting Medicaid for good measure.  (Brooke Gladstone of On the Media has a good summary this week of the impact of block granting Welfare to the states during the Clinton administration. States’ refusal to expand Medicaid under the ACA gives us a good sense of how this would work!)

Clinton got one more health care comment into a discussion of her 30 years of public service.

Eight million kids every year have health insurance, because when I was first lady I worked with Democrats and Republicans to create the Children’s Health Insurance Program. Hundreds of thousands of kids now have a chance to be adopted because I worked to change our adoption and foster care system. After 9/11, I went to work with Republican mayor, governor and president to rebuild New York and to get health care for our first responders who were suffering because they had run toward danger and gotten sickened by it. Hundreds of thousands of National Guard and Reserve members have health care because of work that I did, and children have safer medicines because I was able to pass a law that required the dosing to be more carefully done.

 So – 1765 words on health care by my count (a bit more than 10% of the total words, as transcribed by Politifact)   It’s clear from this that Clinton has a deep understanding of health care – and an appreciation that reforming an existing system that is 1/6 of the economy and is caring for almost all Americans is very difficult.   Donald Trump repeated standard speaking points.

RANDevaluated the Trump health care plan, vague as it is, and determined that it would lead to loss of coverage for 20 million Americans with an increase in the federal deficit, while Clinton’s plan would increase those insured by 9 million with a larger but not huge increase in the federal deficit. 

Presidents don’t create health care policy on their own, and any elected President will have to work with Congress as well as health care stakeholders, including patients, providers, insurers, pharmaceutical companies, employers and others to drive reform.   Health care value will only increase as the delivery of health care itself is improved. The financial system undergirding health care can support or hinder this transformation –but it cannot alone improve the value of health care.