Tampilkan postingan dengan label Obamacare. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Obamacare. Tampilkan semua postingan

Selasa, 01 Agustus 2017

 Maybe a bipartisan health plan is possible?

Maybe a bipartisan health plan is possible?


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 5
 

John McCain rose to the occasion last week and cast one of 51 deciding votes against the ill-named Health Care Freedom Act, aka skinny repeal, which would have led to loss of health coverage for 16 million Americans.    The "repeal and replace Obamacare" movement has been declared dead, although yesterday President Trump tweeted continued threats to blow up the exchanges by not continuing Cost Sharing Reduction payments, and even threatened to stop paying the employer portion of health care premiums for Congressmen and their staffers.  So the effort to repeal is not dead.

A bipartisan group of 40 moderate Republicans and Democrats in the House has just offered ` to increase stability of the individual markets and lower health care costs.  This was first reported on Politico on Sunday.  I'm not confident that Paul Ryan would ever bring this bill up for debate - and if he did, it's not clear there are enough votes to pass it.  But there are some good ideas here.  The five pillars of this legislation

  1. Fund the Cost Sharing Reductions.  They are necessary for exchange policies to be useful for those with low incomes (but over 133% of the federal poverty level), to be sure that their out of pocket costs for care don't make their ACA plans useless.  The dollars in the federal budget are small, and it's likely that health plans would raise premiums (which the feds are also on the hook to pay) -so the winners here will be those with over 400% of FPL income who get insurance on the exchange without subsidies.  This will be hard for Republicans to swallow - it increases federal expenditures.
     
  2. Create a dedicated stability fund for the states.  This could be used to create reinsurance so that health plans didn't have to worry so much about enrolling the sickest of the sick - which would be an important complement for "guarantee issue."  Like funding CSRs, this would be a big Republican give.
     
  3. Exempt employers with 51-499 employees from the employer mandate.   No employer has paid employer mandate penalties so far as this mandate has been delayed, and most employers would intend to continue employer coverage regardless.  This could lead to some losing insurance, though - so it will be a bitter pill for Democrats committed to universal coverage.
     
  4. Repeal of medical device tax.  This tax has also been delayed - it would have raised $20 billion over 10 years.   It's not critical to the success of the Affordable Care Act or the individual exchanges.  Congressmen and women on both sides of the aisle would be fine with this.
     
  5. Promote sale of health plans across state lines.   This is already live in a number of states, and the health plans have expressed no interest.   States with more rigorous regulation of their health care insurance markets will continue to oppose federal preemption of their regulation, and further fragmentation of the health plan markets could lead to higher prices.   States will also worry rightly that a state far away won't be as vigorous in insuring health plan financial stability.  Democrats won't like this - especially since the regulations will be written by the Trump Administration. But getting CSRs and a reinsurance type fund might be worth the dangers this could cause.  Here's an older KFF brief on the subject, and a recent Sarah Kliff review (see item (4))

So - perhaps my estimation of the potential for a bipartisan approach was needlessly pessimistic.   The Republicans might not share the Democratic commitment to universal coverage, but they are not willing to wrench coverage away from millions.  The Democrats know they are in the minority - and appear willing to accept some painful compromises.

Again - it's not clear that the House will act on this proposal - but it's heartening to see some bipartisan efforts to improve health care take root.

Jumat, 28 Juli 2017

Making America Number One in Health

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 3

A large number of Republican Senators expressed doubt and concern about all three of the Republican repeal plans that failed to pass the Senate over the past few days.   Lindsay Graham pointed out that "skinny repeal"" would have disrupted the individual markets in many states. Rob Portman and Shelly Moore Capito and Dean Heller worried that Medicaid cuts would have devastated their states.   Yet all of these Senators voted for various versions of the bills they had decried.  They voted for them with mere hours (or less) to review the bills, which the Congressional Budget Office estimated would lead to 33 million more uninsured (full repeal with no replacement), 22 million more uninsured (repeal and replace), and 16 million more uninsured (skinny repeal).

John McCain stepped up and joined Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins to stop the "skinny repeal" in the wee hours this morning - although all three have faced pressure from Mitch McConnell and taunts and threats from Donald Trump. Paul Ryan even offered promises of a Conference Committee - trying to reassure Senators that the House would not simply pass the Senate bill as is. 

I expect Zombie Obamacare Repeal will be back, and there's no guarantee that the Republicans won't get the votes in the future.    But for now, we've dodged another bullet - and efforts to throw 1/6 of the US economy into turmoil have at least been put off.

We can't fool ourselves into thinking that we have preserved a wonderful system, though. The Commonwealth Fund continues to remind us that our system is the most expensive in the world, and we have the worst outcomes of all developed countries.

Eric Schneider and colleagues of the Commonwealth Fund had a perspective piece published on nejm.org two weeks ago that pointed to four ways the US health care could transition to being the "number one" health care system in the world. It's good to read commentaries from forward looking optimists at a time when public policy seems so grim. Their suggestions didn't involve more money, but would require fundamental rethinking of how we finance, organize, and deliver health care.   Repeal of Obamacare would make it virtually impossible to achieve these goals. 

  1. Lack of access: This is driven largely by cost barriers - and has to be solved by a combination of providing more generous insurance to lower out of pocket payments - but we also will need to genuinely lower the cost of health care.   Higher deductibles and more cost sharing will just make this worse.
  2. Underinvestment in primary care:  I would have instead characterized the problem as overinvestment in expensive specialty care.  The authors would have us increase primary care capacity - although I doubt costs would come down without decreasing specialty capacity.
  3. Administrative inefficiency:  The authors note that our finance system leads to multiple layers of value-destroying costs.  These are pretty entrenched, but simplifying systems and getting rid of administrative costs would help.
  4. Disparities:  As long as disparities continue to be so striking, we will continue to have terrible outcomes for those with less access (to health care and perhaps more importantly to environments that promote healthier behavior).

It's hard to see us making progress on these four fronts when we have a Congress and Administration focused on lowering taxes on the super-rich, willing to toss tens of millions off insurance, ignoring climate change and dismantling the bipartisan legacy of environmental protection.   Red states like Texas in the vanguard of the Trumpist approach to health care and to government now see shocking increases in rates of maternal mortality, and decreases in life expectancy. 

But staving off repeal (for now) at least means we'll not be even further behind when we have the next opportunity to improve health after the departure of the current administration.   We owe a debt of gratitude to McCain (and Murkowski and Collins) for keeping us from further backsliding early this morning.  

Selasa, 20 Juni 2017

Job-Killing TrumpCare

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 924,000

AHCA Job Losses by State 
 

The Senate continues to push toward a July 4 deadline to complete its work on the American Health Care Act (AHCA), and most reports suggest that the bill is likely to look much like the House version, which would cut $800 billion from Medicaid, allow states to opt out of the Affordable Care Act insurance reforms that protect those with preexisting conditions, and lead to 23 million more Americans without health insurance.

Of course, we don't really know, since there have been no hearings and there is no proposed language for the bill that has been released to the public.   As Stephen Colbert said, the Republican bill is "as secret as the next season of Game of Thrones, but more people will die."

The Commonwealth Fund published research from George Washington University last week that showed the likely impact of the AHCA on Gross Domestic Product and employment by state.

The results demonstrate why the Republicans want to pass this bill in secret. 

The researchers projected that the large tax cut would initially create as many as 864,000 new jobs shortly after the bill passed -but by 2026 the legislation would have destroyed 924,000 jobs - about 3/4 of them in health care.  Further, business output would be lower by $148 billion and gross state product (I think that's the GDP by state) would be down by $93 billion. 

This doesn't even include the additional $600m cut in Medicaid in Trump's 2018 fiscal year budget proposal.

The Trump Administration is proposing tax cuts that will only be responsible if we achieve a 3% GDP growth.   Never mind the millions who will be harmed by lack of health insurance, this is a poor start on increasing our economic growth rate.   I continue to be hopeful that moderate Republicans will insist on enough concessions that the conservative fringe of the Republican party will choose to forego the ACA repeal.

The Republicans decried Obamacare as "job killing," and Donald Trump claimed that repeal would lead to 2 million new jobs.    That's a certifiable alt-fact.

Source 

Kamis, 15 Juni 2017

Wresting health insurance from 23 million without a single hearing

Wresting health insurance from 23 million without a single hearing



Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  Zero


Under cover of a metastasizing Russia scandal, news the Special Counsel is investigating the President for obstruction of justice, and the heinous gun attack on the Republican congressional baseball team practice, you'd almost never know that the Senate is poised to put the final nails in the coffin of ObamaCare. 

There have been articles - and good ones - describing Mitch McConnell's strategy to pass a bill ("any bill") without telling the public anything about the bill.  These include reporting by Sarah Kliff, Julie Rovner, an op ed by David Leonhardt.

Leonhardt also pointed out that the parties you'd think would be advocating tirelessly against the American Health Care Act, including the American Hospital Association, are strangely quiet.  The AHA just asked the Trump Administration to scuttle the Medicare Stars program (rating hospital quality) and not require future meaningful use of electronic medical records.  Perhaps there is a quid pro quo?

The New York Times posted an article about the secrecy of the Senate health care bill this afternoon.  The authors recount the not-secret-at-all origins of the Affordable Care Act:

The Senate health committee approved its version in July 2009 after considering hundreds of amendments over 13 days. The Senate Finance Committee cleared its version in October 2009, after more than a year of hearings, round-table discussions and other spadework. A group of Democrats and Republicans from the Finance Committee met for months behind closed doors, trying — but ultimately failing — to draft bipartisan legislation.

The full Senate passed the Affordable Care Act on Dec. 24, 2009, on the 25th consecutive day of floor debate.


Health care represents over 1/6 of the US economy. A party that got 3 million fewer votes in the Presidential election and lost House and Senate seats in the 2016 election is about to take health insurance away from 23 million people without a single hearing and without a Congressional Budget Office score.  

It's easy to be deeply distressed.

Kamis, 13 April 2017

Administration encourages insurers to bail on exchanges


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $7 billion




What if we had an insurance exchange and no insurers came?

That’s the worry this week in health policy circles, as the Trump Administration refuses to commit to reimburse insurers for the “cost sharing reduction” that caps expenditures for those making under 250% of the federal poverty limit.  CSRs are expected to be a total of $7 billion next year – and if insurers thought they would not be reimbursed, they would have to hike premiums by 19%.  Source: Kaiser Family Foundation
CSRs

Here is why this matters.  

Insurance companies must decide by next month whether to participate in the Obamacare exchanges.  They could model their decisions based on assumptions either that the Trump Administration continues to pay the CSR fees.  If they believe the CSR fees would continue – they would price their ACA exchange plans much as they do now.  If they believe the CSR fees would be discontinued, they could increase their exchange prices by 19% (on average – it would be 27% in Mississippi).

The problem is that if they bet they have to charge the extra fees and they are wrong, they will lose pretty much all healthy members (who will go to the lower cost plans), and they will still lose a bundle.   If they bet the CSR reimbursement will continue and they are wrong, they will not suffer adverse selection – but they will lose their shirts anyway.    Essentially- there is no margin for error because all decisions would be catastrophic if the insurer misjudged the Trump administration’s plans.   What insurance company CFO in her right mind would continue to offer products on the exchange? 

Some have suggested that the feds will owe this money sooner or later- as the ACA requires it whether or not there are Congressional appropriations.   However, in the long run we are all dead (John Maynard Keynes) –and insurance companies are judged by quarterly earnings and risk based capital –so can’t afford a multiyear battle to capture funds owed by the feds.   Just ask the CEOs of the Co-Op Plans – but you can’t because the majority went bust when the government didn’t fund the risk corridor reimbursements (thanks, Marco Rubio).

So – if the Trump Administration wants the Obamacare exchanges to die, it need just continue to send mixed messages about whether it will continue to pay the CSR reimbursements, as required by the ACA but opposed by the House of Representatives.

Sarah Kliff of Vox.com on Trump Administration's mixed messages 
Carolyn Johnson of Wonkblog on mixed messages 

Selasa, 28 Maret 2017

Republicans CAN save Obamacare!

Republicans CAN save Obamacare!

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 150,000


Obamacare has had more than its share of detractors, but it also has real problems.   Most of these are problems that could be addressed with straightforward legislation and thoughtful regulation -and now that the Trump Administration and Paul Ryan have stated that the ACA is the "law of the land," here is how they could address the ACA's problems.  Many of the solutions I'm noting here are anathema to conservatives - but perhaps there is hope. 

David Leonhardt noted today in the NY Times that the executive branch could easily destroy the individual markets - which serve those between 133% and 400% of the federal poverty level.   It could encourage more uncertainty or more adverse selection, and insurers will run.  Medicaid is harder to dislodge without 60 votes in the Senate.   It would be ironic  if the Republicans strangled the exchanges, which utilize private health insurance plans and were initially designed by conservatives at the Heritage Foundation, while they provided ongoing support for Medicaid, which is a government program with no free market elements.


Here are the major problems with the ACA, and what the Republicans could do to address these problems

Too few healthy people have enrolled.

The AHCA tried to solve this by allowing insurers to charge older people more. This might have chased away the old and sick - but on its own would not recruit a lot of young healthy folks.   To attract more of the young healthy into the exchanges:
  • Enforce the individual penalty (and make it larger)
  • Advertise!
  • Keep the rates low - perhaps through larger subsidies
  • Assure all that the cost sharing reductions will remain in place .  See Monday's post on this.   Good news is The Hill reports that senior Republicans are supporting this.

The out of pocket costs of health plans are too high, as are the premiums for those without subsidies.

Out of Pocket: The CSR helps those below 250% of FPL -these could be extended to higher incomes.  (They phase out at 250% of FPL - this could be at 400% or more).

Premium Costs: Subsidies for those under 400% of FPL are a big help.   But even those at 400% of FPL have a hard time affording premiums, especially in rural areas.  We could put in place a hard limit to portion of income that could be spent on premiums for a basic plan, making plans affordable for more.

Efforts to lower the overall costs of health care are critical here - that includes aggressive market-based payment reform, like bidding first for commodities (like durable medical equipment) and later for other medical services.  

The FDA could consider safety, efficacy, AND cost effectiveness.   That feels like more regulations- but if we want less expensive health care like the rest of the developed world, we need to control pharmaceutical costs.

We could think about price ceilings, perhaps as a percent of Medicare, too. This would diminish much of the effort currently spent on negotiation - and could allow more aggressive competition among health plans.   Health plan fragmentation would no longer allow exceptionally high prices.

Too few people are covered

Medicaid is the least expensive way to provide medical care for the poor and near poor.   19 states could expand Medicaid -- which would increase coverage by over 4 million.   This could also help take some pressure off of the exchanges, where those under 133% of FPL who had signed up had disproportionate illness - raising premiums for all exchange enrollees.  Of course this means that the government will pay - but it will do so at a reduced rate, and Medicaid programs have been exceptionally effective at providing health care to those with extreme needs.   Breaking news - Kansasis now (again) considering Medicaid expansion.   The State Senate passed  Medicaid expansion overwhelmingly last year but it was vetoed by Governor Sam Brownback.   This could cover 150,000 additional Kansans.


So- there it is. The big ACA problems - and how to fix them.   If the Republicans want to make the ACA's exchanges work - they can do it.