Tampilkan postingan dengan label Health Affairs. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Health Affairs. Tampilkan semua postingan

Selasa, 18 April 2017

Malpractice payouts down 55.7%


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $61.9 billion


Congress is now considering a Republican bill to restrict malpractice lawsuits – and touting this as a way to decrease the cost of medical care.  That’s important – as there is widespread agreement that we need to lower the cost of health care (not just shift more costs to patients).

HR 1215, introduced by Steve King of Iowa, would
-        Cap noneconomic damages at $250,000
-        Cap punitive damages at $500,000
-        Shorten statute of limitations to 1 year after discovery of injury (3 years for kids)
-        Limit liability to “share” of liability.  (This would wreak havoc in Massachusetts, where nonprofit hospital liability is limited to $20K, so physician malpractice carriers pay the vast majority of settlements for care delivered in hospitals regardless of who is at fault.
-        Allow life insurance or other payouts to reduce payment to successful litigant
-        Cap attorney fees (to under 1/3 as soon as payout exceeds $100K)
The total cost of malpractice claims represents a tiny portion of medical costs – so the goal is to decrease physician defensive medicine.  The challenge is that physicians who practice in states that already severely restricted malpractice claims have not changed their view of the risk of malpractice.


We found high levels of malpractice concern among both generalists and specialists in states where objective measures of malpractice risk were low. 

At a minimum it will take a long time for such a bill to substantially reduce excessive lab tests or imaging tests that are categorized as defensive medicine.

The Congressional Budget Office weighed in on this in December – and its analysis suggests that the bill would lower the federal deficit by $61.9 billion over a decade (mostly by lowering costs of Medicare, Medicaid, and ACA subsidies, but also representing lower tax loss as employer sponsored health insurance costs decrease.  

Further, the number and total payout from malpractice claims has plummeted in recent years.  JAMA Internal Medicine published data showing that paid malpractice claims declined by 55.7% from 2009-2014. 

I’m not confident that the savings promised by HR 1215 would be realized because physician behavior change requires such long intervals.  This bill feels to me like a solution in search of a problem given the decline in malpractice payouts.

Jumat, 17 Februari 2017

Low wage workers use less preventive care and have more illness

This exhibit shows that high wage workers are more likely to have any claims at all. One could infer that deductibles were discouraging low wage workers from entering the system much more than they discourage high wage workers. 


Low wage workers are most likely to have no claims at all. One could infer that deductibles  discouraged low wage workers from entering the system much more than they discouraged high wage workers. 

Researchers from Case Western report on differences between medical utilization of lower and higher wage workers in this month's Health Affairs - and the results are disheartening.  (H/T to Michelle Andrews of Kaiser Health News who reported on this study today).

Using claims from about 43,000 covered employees over a single year (2014) and four self-insured employers who offered a combination of high deductible and preferred provider organization plans, researchers found
…the lowest-wage group had half the usage of preventive care (19 percent versus 38 percent), nearly twice the hospital admission rate (31 individuals per 1,000 versus 17 per 1,000), more than four times the rate of avoidable admissions (4.3 individuals per 1,000 versus 0.9 per 1,000), and more than three times the rate of emergency department visits (370 individuals per 1,000 versus 120 per 1,000) relative to top-wage-group earners.


Low wage workers also had the lowest medication possession rates.  The researchers report that annual deductibles were about 10% of average income for lowest wage quintile, and 1% of average income for highest wage quintile.

The charts below show that avoidable emergency department use was highest in low wage workers, while use of preventive care was highest in high wage workers    The bottom graph might look confusing at first- the orange bar represents costs per patient who had any claims at all; the purple bar uses a denominator of all members including the roughly 20% who incur no medical claims.




Note in last graphic  that purple uses all members as denominator, and orange uses only those members who had medical claims

There's a lot that this study does not show.  The researchers didn't focus on out of pocket expenses - so we don't get a sense of which health plans were "better" or "worse" for lower wage  workers.  They only evaluated employee (not dependent) care, and had no access  to spouse income so some families could be mislabeled as to their total income.  One can't impute what level of health care spending is "optimal," and we certainly can't assume that the additional preventive care delivered to higher wage employees was in any was causal of lower emergency department and inpatient costs.

Employer sponsored health insurance (ESI) once promoted increased economic equity.   With insurance, those of modest wages could "afford" the same cure of cancer or treatment of a heart attack as their wealthy colleagues.   ESI has always offered more benefits to higher wage workers, though, as the tax deductibility is worth little for those at the bottom end of the wage scale. 

 Years of "consumerism" and decreasing employer subsidies have chipped away at affordability of elective care at the site of service - and this has probably decreased delivery of high value preventive services more to those with the lowest wages.

Jumat, 09 Desember 2016

Fluoride in the water prevents cavities AND saves money


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is $6.8 billion

Source 

This month's Health Affairs is focused on oral care.    Dental care represents about 5% of total out of pocket health care spending, and access to dental insurance is highly variable. Those at highest risk for dental disease, the elderly, are much less likely to have dental insurance (38%) than those of working age (67%). LINK  Dental insurance often has benefit caps which mean that a substantial amount of cost remains out of pocket.

One of the biggest public health successes of the last century is Floridization of water -which decreases dental caries by at least 25%.    My mouth is filled with amalgam - and every few years I need a crown for a tooth that can no longer be refilled.   My adult children are cavity free.  But Floridization remains inexplicably (to me) controversial - and 27% of children grow up in communities without fluoridated water.

Researcherscalculated costs of adding fluoride to community water supply, and projected cost savings from decrease in cavities only.   The answer:

Based on 2013 estimated costs ($324 million), net savings (savings minus costs) from fluoridation systems were estimated to be $6,469 million and the estimated return on investment, 20.0.

This substantially understates the true benefit of floridization of community water supplies.   Those prevented cavities don't merely decrease future cost of dental care - they likely decrease costs of other medical care - as well as lost economic input from decreased job opportunities for those who have bad teeth.
  Cost of Caries 

Senin, 07 November 2016

California Ballot Initiative Aims to Lower Drug Prices

California Ballot Initiative Aims to Lower Drug Prices


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 61



California will vote on Proposition 61 tomorrow; the ballot initiative would mandate that California pay no more than the Veteran’s Administration (VA) for pharmaceutical prices.   This would apply to $3.8 billion in drug spending by Medical (California’s Medicaid program), state workers, and retirees.  It’s an unworkable proposal –but still could achieve its goals.

Health Affairs has a blog post explaining the measure, which is being opposed by the Pharma industry (over $100 million in expected spending), and promoted by the California Nurses Association, the AIDS HealthCare Foundation, the California AARP and others.   It’s also opposed by the LA Times and the SF Chronicle,

The measure is unworkable because

1.     The VA has a limited formulary – so can negotiate lower prices.   Medicaid rules prevent the state from having a limited formulary for non-managed Medicaid.
2.     There are NO VA prices for the drugs not in its formulary –so the measure would fail to control the prices of those drugs.
3.     The state doesn’t have the ability to force drug companies to sell their products at the mandated price, which could lead to shortages or drugs being unavailable.

The measure is economically unwise because mandating a “most favored nation (MFN)  price generally increases the price for all purchasers.   When Medicaid MFN was introduced in the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1990,  it raised the overall price of drugs by about 4%- because having to give a rebate to Medicaid whenever a private payer struck a good deal helped the pharmaceutical companies enforce price discipline.   Here’s a link to a 2010 blog post on this subject .

But still. 

This ballot initiative puts pressure on pharmaceutical companies to keep prices lower, and puts pressure on the state as a purchaser to negotiate hard.  Its authors might realize the measure would be almost impossible to enforce –but are looking to draw public attention as part of a campaign to control drug prices.  

There is an analogous example about how the initial“Romneycare” health care reform was passed in Massachusetts.  Unions and the advocacy group Health Care for All had the support to place a constitutional amendment on the ballot to guarantee access to affordable comprehensive health care.   The health care reform that passed was much more acceptable to the system stakeholders than this ballot initiative – and so reform moved forward. 

Selasa, 04 Oktober 2016

Better quality hospitals save Medicare $$ - Might not apply to other health plans


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $2698


Researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health report in the September issue of Health Affairs that Medicare saves money when certain surgical procedures are performed in the highest quality hospitals compared to the lowest quality hospitals.  That’s a big deal – it means that there is no “tradeoff” necessary where we must pay more for better quality!

The researchers evaluated hospitals for care of six different surgical episodes (cardiac bypass, lung lobectomy, endovascular aortic aneurism repair, colectomy and hip replacement.)  They top hospitals were in the lowest quartile for risk adjusted 30 day mortality and in the top quartile for patient experience by survey, and the bottom hospitals were those with highest rate of 30 day mortality with lowest scores on the patient experience surveys.  The researchers also found that others measures of surgical quality were well correlated with the mortality measure. 

Medicare spent $2698 less in the high quality hospitals compared to the low quality hospitals!

The majority of the savings were from decreased postacute care (60%) and prevented readmissions (20%) –validating the idea that high quality hospitals save dollars by preventing complications.  Outpatient care costs were slightly higher. The differences were statistically significant for hip replacement and colectomy – and did not reach statistical significance for the other procedures, which have lower volume.

Unfortunately, this data is not relevant to commercial health plans, those which serve employed populations.  Medicare sets prices, and the prices at (often high quality) academic medical centers are only a small amount more than prices at lesser nonacademic institutions.  Commercial insurers must negotiation prices with each hospital, and those high quality academic institutions often have huge leverage in contracting talks, and can have dramatically higher rates.  So it’s quite likely that the savings of 8.7% would be washed away by rates that were higher by substantially more.

We should still preferentially send patients to the best hospitals - the ones with lowest surgical complication rate and best patient experience.  That movement will likely force other hospitals to improve their quality and service, too.  

But this study's promise of savings from this approach is only relevant for Medicare which sets prices. 

Source (doesn't add to 100% due to rounding)