Tampilkan postingan dengan label Graham Cassidy. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Graham Cassidy. Tampilkan semua postingan

Selasa, 19 September 2017

Another Round of Zombie TrumpCare

Another Round of Zombie TrumpCare

Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 50


We might have thought that the Republicans would give up on repealing the Affordable Care Act (ACA)  - since they have come up with no alternative that would not lead to tens of millions more uninsured. Many of their proposals would paradoxically increase the cost of health care – whether through increasing premium subsidy cost by eliminating subsidies that decrease out of pocket costs for the poor, by removing minimum medical loss ratios, or removing prohibitions on physician ownership of ambulatory facilities.

But Graham-Cassidyis here – and it’s been blessed by “moderates” like Dean Heller.  John McCain and Lindsey Graham are best friends -- so he might just vote for this bill.   and Bill Cassidy is a physician from Louisiana,  a state that just over 400,000 new residents with its Medicaid expansion, and decreased the uninsured rate from 21.7% to 12.7%.   


The bill would make massive cuts in Medicaid –much like the other plans that the CBO projected would lead to loss of insurance by more than 20 million Americans.  It would change funding for both Medicaid and exchange subsidies to be a block grant to states – and redistribute the smaller pot of money from states that had expanded Medicaid to those which did not.   It would allow states to waive the essential benefits and the insurance reforms of the ACA –so goodbye to protections for the sick.  It would allow catastrophic health plans and mini-med health plans, prohibit any tax credits to any plan that covered abortions, and explicitly allow states to impose work requirements for Medicaid beneficiaries.   The individual mandate would lapse- making the insured pool sicker and therefore increasing health care premiums.

The R’s have less than two weeks to get a Congressional Budget Office (CBO) score and an approval from the Senate Parliamentarian to pass this egregious bill under the “reconciliation” procedure that requires only 50 votes (with VP Mike Pence as a tiebreaker).  But they can do it – and the pressure on that 50th Republican Senator to not be the one who prevented this travesty will be massive.

Some argue that state based programs are better than a federal program because states are able to be more nimble and innovative, and what’s good for Massachusetts is simply not what is good for Mississippi.    Here are four reasons why moving Medicaid to state block grants is a terrible public policy idea.

1.     Medicaid spending spikes during economic recessions – and the feds can run a deficit but the states cannot. So block granting this program (even if it were not woefully underfunded) doesn’t make economic sense.
2.     Nineteen states have not expanded Medicaid given the option with almost no state contribution– proving that their politicians are simply not committed to addressing the problem of uninsurance.   In Alabama a family of four cannot qualify for Medicaid unless their income is less than $4000 a year.   I’m not sure what makes us think that the state would be any more likely to use these new funds to bolster care for the poor.   
3.     We want more labor flexibility – especially in an environment with low unemployment.  Medicaid eligibility rules changing at the state line doesn’t help this.
4.     States are not especially adept at technology  - and many states (including well-meaning blue states) wasted scads of money trying to set up their exchanges only to throw their hands in the air and opt for joining the federal exchange.  Technology will be key to sending all possible dollars toward health care –and not toward administrative costs.

Many governors would like a big block grant.  Money is fungible –and they could use that block grant to supplant other funds the state previously spent on public health or health care and free up those dollars to go to other priorities.   We would likely see regressive tax cuts and giveaways to well-connected hospitals.  

I’m hopeful that Graham-Cassidy is here too late to upend the health insurance market.  But I’m not sure.  And I’m worried.

Rabu, 13 September 2017

Dueling visions of health care policy

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 30 million


Two competing health plans have been in the news today. Bernie Sanders has rolled out his "Medicare for All" plan, and the Lindsey Graham Bill Cassidy proposal has gained new "moderate" support and will be yet another Republican attempt to repeal Obamacare.

First, the Republican plan.   David Leonhart titled his post on this "New TrumpCare Deserves a Quick Death." He points out that although the sponsors claim that this bill would allow states freedom to innovate - it would rapidly decrease the available funds.  Even states committed to universal health care access might be hacking away at the number of those with subsidized insurance very quickly.  The Congressional Budget Office hasn't weighed in yet -but this bill is close enough to past TrumpCare bills that he estimates it would lead to 15 million additional uninsured in 2018, and 30 million losing insurance over the next decade.

It's hard to say that Graham-Cassidy absolutely won'tpass, and it would be a deeply disruptive bill that would make health care in the US much worse than it currently is.  The more time Congress spends on that bill, the less effort it will put into the market fixes we so desperately need for the Affordable Care Act.

With great fanfare, Bernie Sanders has introduced his Medicare for All plan today.   He has 17 cosponsors in the Senate (he had none when he introduced his last universal health care bill), and about 60% of House Democrats have endorsed a different universal health care bill.   The Sanders approach is aspirational - In an interview with Vox, he says:

I mean, this is a big issue, and we are introducing comprehensive legislation at a time when we have Donald Trump as president, who wanted to throw 32 million people off the health insurance. You know, Mitch McConnell, Paul Ryan, running the Senate and the House. We're not going to get this thing done with these guys in power.

Sarah Kliff has a summary of the details of the Sander's plan.   The initial plan was explicit about benefits and cost sharing (rich benefits for all, no substantial cost sharing for patients) and mum on costs; this afternoon he released additional details including a 7.5% employer payroll tax exempting small businesses (that's much less than most employers spend on health coverage), and a 4% income tax on individuals exempting low income people. For many, this would be a good deal.

And that's the problem.   If Sanders is able to provide insurance for all with close to no cost sharing (which means there will be more discretionary utilization), it's either going to cost more (much more, as California discovered) or providers will be paid much less.  The Sanders plan would create a national fee schedule (Medicare), but would increase payment to providers caring for Medicaid beneficiaries.   The decline in provider reimbursement would have to be huge to provide enough savings to make this work.

We need meaningful reform of the health care system - and we need lower unit prices.  There will be plenty of time to evaluate whether the Sanders plan is the best way to get to universal access - and I'm in favor of modest cost sharing as opposed to no cost sharing at all.  Today lets us all see the vision of each party -- one is satisfied to leave 30 million additional Americans uninsured; the other wants to insure everyone, but there is a danger that this is the "unicorn" plan in that it is rooted in fiction in that it might not be affordable.