Tampilkan postingan dengan label Commonwealth Fund. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label Commonwealth Fund. Tampilkan semua postingan

Jumat, 28 Juli 2017

Making America Number One in Health

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 3

A large number of Republican Senators expressed doubt and concern about all three of the Republican repeal plans that failed to pass the Senate over the past few days.   Lindsay Graham pointed out that "skinny repeal"" would have disrupted the individual markets in many states. Rob Portman and Shelly Moore Capito and Dean Heller worried that Medicaid cuts would have devastated their states.   Yet all of these Senators voted for various versions of the bills they had decried.  They voted for them with mere hours (or less) to review the bills, which the Congressional Budget Office estimated would lead to 33 million more uninsured (full repeal with no replacement), 22 million more uninsured (repeal and replace), and 16 million more uninsured (skinny repeal).

John McCain stepped up and joined Lisa Murkowski and Susan Collins to stop the "skinny repeal" in the wee hours this morning - although all three have faced pressure from Mitch McConnell and taunts and threats from Donald Trump. Paul Ryan even offered promises of a Conference Committee - trying to reassure Senators that the House would not simply pass the Senate bill as is. 

I expect Zombie Obamacare Repeal will be back, and there's no guarantee that the Republicans won't get the votes in the future.    But for now, we've dodged another bullet - and efforts to throw 1/6 of the US economy into turmoil have at least been put off.

We can't fool ourselves into thinking that we have preserved a wonderful system, though. The Commonwealth Fund continues to remind us that our system is the most expensive in the world, and we have the worst outcomes of all developed countries.

Eric Schneider and colleagues of the Commonwealth Fund had a perspective piece published on nejm.org two weeks ago that pointed to four ways the US health care could transition to being the "number one" health care system in the world. It's good to read commentaries from forward looking optimists at a time when public policy seems so grim. Their suggestions didn't involve more money, but would require fundamental rethinking of how we finance, organize, and deliver health care.   Repeal of Obamacare would make it virtually impossible to achieve these goals. 

  1. Lack of access: This is driven largely by cost barriers - and has to be solved by a combination of providing more generous insurance to lower out of pocket payments - but we also will need to genuinely lower the cost of health care.   Higher deductibles and more cost sharing will just make this worse.
  2. Underinvestment in primary care:  I would have instead characterized the problem as overinvestment in expensive specialty care.  The authors would have us increase primary care capacity - although I doubt costs would come down without decreasing specialty capacity.
  3. Administrative inefficiency:  The authors note that our finance system leads to multiple layers of value-destroying costs.  These are pretty entrenched, but simplifying systems and getting rid of administrative costs would help.
  4. Disparities:  As long as disparities continue to be so striking, we will continue to have terrible outcomes for those with less access (to health care and perhaps more importantly to environments that promote healthier behavior).

It's hard to see us making progress on these four fronts when we have a Congress and Administration focused on lowering taxes on the super-rich, willing to toss tens of millions off insurance, ignoring climate change and dismantling the bipartisan legacy of environmental protection.   Red states like Texas in the vanguard of the Trumpist approach to health care and to government now see shocking increases in rates of maternal mortality, and decreases in life expectancy. 

But staving off repeal (for now) at least means we'll not be even further behind when we have the next opportunity to improve health after the departure of the current administration.   We owe a debt of gratitude to McCain (and Murkowski and Collins) for keeping us from further backsliding early this morning.  

Selasa, 20 Juni 2017

Job-Killing TrumpCare

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 924,000

AHCA Job Losses by State 
 

The Senate continues to push toward a July 4 deadline to complete its work on the American Health Care Act (AHCA), and most reports suggest that the bill is likely to look much like the House version, which would cut $800 billion from Medicaid, allow states to opt out of the Affordable Care Act insurance reforms that protect those with preexisting conditions, and lead to 23 million more Americans without health insurance.

Of course, we don't really know, since there have been no hearings and there is no proposed language for the bill that has been released to the public.   As Stephen Colbert said, the Republican bill is "as secret as the next season of Game of Thrones, but more people will die."

The Commonwealth Fund published research from George Washington University last week that showed the likely impact of the AHCA on Gross Domestic Product and employment by state.

The results demonstrate why the Republicans want to pass this bill in secret. 

The researchers projected that the large tax cut would initially create as many as 864,000 new jobs shortly after the bill passed -but by 2026 the legislation would have destroyed 924,000 jobs - about 3/4 of them in health care.  Further, business output would be lower by $148 billion and gross state product (I think that's the GDP by state) would be down by $93 billion. 

This doesn't even include the additional $600m cut in Medicaid in Trump's 2018 fiscal year budget proposal.

The Trump Administration is proposing tax cuts that will only be responsible if we achieve a 3% GDP growth.   Never mind the millions who will be harmed by lack of health insurance, this is a poor start on increasing our economic growth rate.   I continue to be hopeful that moderate Republicans will insist on enough concessions that the conservative fringe of the Republican party will choose to forego the ACA repeal.

The Republicans decried Obamacare as "job killing," and Donald Trump claimed that repeal would lead to 2 million new jobs.    That's a certifiable alt-fact.

Source 

Selasa, 13 Juni 2017

Tiered networks save $; Teaching hospitals can save your life

Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 1.5%

Exchange plans have gravitated to narrow networks - and many have been encouraged that narrow networks allow higher value while being an important element of leverage with provider systems that have excellent reputations, high market leverage and command premium pricing.  Most of these high-leverage systems are anchored by academic medical centers (AMCs).  AMCs have higher costs than non-teaching hospitals because:

  • They do teaching - which increases costs as trainees order extra tests or are less efficient
  • They offer highly specialized services which have low volume
  • They take care of the sickest of the sick - and even risk adjustment probably doesn't fully reflect the real resource costs of the care they provide.

Nonetheless, it's been hard to show any correlation between this higher cost and better quality or better outcomes -and narrow networks that restrict access to the highest priced systems have proliferated, and have seemed like a good idea.

Employer plans have followed - narrow networks are frankly much more attractive than additional cost shifting to members who already face substantially more out of pocket spending than they did a few years ago.

The Commonwealth Fund showed that in Massachusetts tiered networks were associated with 5% lower costs - with no apparent loss of quality.  In Massachusetts, though, academic medical centers deliver an outsized portion of total care, and few narrow networks exclude all major teaching hospitals.

Lower metallic level plans across the country are increasingly offering no access to AMCs.  This could be a challenge for people who have severe illnesses where AMCs are required.  Presumably these plan do pay for AMC care for patients who need liver transplants or the most specialized of care -- but patients and their physicians need to jump through difficult hoops that are a special challenge to patients and their families confronting catastrophic illness.

JAMApublished research late last month that represents a challenge to narrow networks.   Researchers reviewed over  21 million Medicare admissions from 2012-2014 to major teaching hospitals (6%), minor teaching hospitals (20%), and nonteaching hospitals (74%).  They found:

Unadjusted 30-day mortality was 8.1% at major teaching hospitals, 9.2% at minor teaching hospitals, and 9.6% at nonteaching hospitals, with a 1.5% (95% CI, 1.3%-1.7%; P<.001) mortality difference between major teaching hospitals and nonteaching hospitals.

The difference persisted after risk adjustment - and was true regardless of the size of the hospital.  (Austin Frakt, one of the researchers, summarized this in the NYTimes Upshot).

Ouch.  This research looks solid.  The sample size is huge (100% of the Medicare database).   The mortality difference isn't from more aggressive diagnosis coding - and the differences are statistically significant in 13 of 15 top DRGs and 5 of 6 surgical categories.  

This is Medicare data - the difference might not be applicable to the population under 65.  Differences among hospitals within each category might still be more important than the difference between teaching hospitals and nonteaching hospitals.  But I think this research poses a serious challenge to the effort, which I've vigorously supported, to move "community" medical care away from the major teaching hospitals.

I believe that adult inpatient care will eventually follow pediatric inpatient care.  Very little inpatient pediatric care is done in non-teaching hospitals at this point.  If kids are sick enough to be in the hospital they are in a teaching hospital - otherwise they are cared for at home.  Many of the conditions that required multiple day hospitalizations when I was in training are now treated on an ambulatory basis.  That trend will continue.

But in the meantime, these researchers have shown us a caution flag in the effort to move inpatient care away from the most expensive inpatient providers.  This will make efforts to control unit prices even more important.




Selasa, 08 November 2016

Elections Matter


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 0


It’s finally here. The countdown clock is at zero, and today is election day.

This has been a dispiriting election season – largely because there is a huge chasm between the two political parties (not just between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton) – and this has gotten virtually no coverage.   The major news networks spent more time on Hillary Clinton’s email servers than all of the candidate’s policy positions.   Even news sources like NPR frankly were far more focused on the horse race and coverage of impolitic statements than the gigantic difference in what each of the parties has said they will do.    And there’s good evidence that presidents, after election, work hard to accomplish what they have said they will do.

I’m reprising a post from September about a RAND study sponsored by the Commonwealth Fund about what electing Hillary Clinton would mean compared electing Donald Trump in terms of health care access and cost.


=======


 



Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 29.4 million


The Commonwealth Fund sponsored RAND to use its health system microsimulator to estimate the impact of the Clinton and the Trump health care plans.  This is important information as we head into the presidential debates –and frankly there has been way too little attention to the health care differences between the two major party presidential nominees. 

The Trump plan, all told, would decrease the number of Americans with insurance, would increase out of pocket spending, and would predominately benefit rich people.  It would increase the federal deficit, although by only a little. 

The Clinton plan would further increase the number of Americans with insurance, decrease out of pocket spending, and predominately benefit those with modest incomes.  It would increase the deficit by substantially more. 

Clinton’s plan would mean 9.1 million more had insurance  - and that insurance would be valuable enough that it would increase family economic security.    The Trump plan would mean 20.3 million fewer Americans had insurance –and even that insurance would provide less protection from economic ruin.   

In total, Clinton’s proposals would mean 29.4 million more insured compared to Trump’s proposals, with insurance that was more likely to shield families from ruin, accompanied by a larger deficit (or other offsetting taxes). 

This is a microsimulation – and it’s only as good as the algorithms built in.  It’s a complex model –but doesn’t take into effect many other things that could change – such as job loss from trade wars, increased military spending, or government shutdowns.   Some of the numbers are a little counterintuitive –  like how could the total impact of Trump’s proposals on the federal deficit be so much less than the impact of the ACA repeal alone. Since multiple outputs are changing simultaneously, viewers can’t sum the numbers in any column and expect them to add up nicely. 

It’s easy to focus on the “horse race” elements of presidential politics – and I’ve been exasperated when I hear millenials (perhaps nonrepresentative) quoted in radio interviews suggesting that there is little difference between Clinton and Trump.  There is a world of difference, and this microsimulation helps illustrate what this could mean to real people in 2018.

Jumat, 23 September 2016

RAND demonstrates Clinton/Trump impact on health care.


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 29.4 million


The Commonwealth Fund sponsored RAND to use its health system microsimulator to estimate the impact of the Clinton and the Trump health care plans.  This is important information as we head into the presidential debates –and frankly there has been way too little attention to the health care differences between the two major party presidential nominees.

The Trump plan, all told, would decrease the number of Americans with insurance, would increase out of pocket spending, and would predominately benefit rich people.  It would increase the federal deficit, although by only a little.

The Clinton plan would further increase the number of Americans with insurance, decrease out of pocket spending, and predominately benefit those with modest incomes.  It would increase the deficit by substantially more.

Clinton’s plan would mean 9.1 million more had insurance  - and that insurance would be valuable enough that it would increase family economic security.    The Trump plan would mean 20.3 million fewer Americans had insurance –and even that insurance would provide less protection from economic ruin.   

In total, Clinton’s proposals would mean 29.4 million more insured compared to Trump’s proposals, with insurance that was more likely to shield families from ruin, accompanied by a larger deficit (or other offsetting taxes).

This is a microsimulation – and it’s only as good as the algorithms built in.  It’s a complex model –but doesn’t take into effect many other things that could change – such as job loss from trade wars, increased military spending, or government shutdowns.   Some of the numbers are a little counterintuitive –  like how could the total impact of Trump’s proposals on the federal deficit be so much less than the impact of the ACA repeal alone. Since multiple outputs are changing simultaneously, viewers can’t sum the numbers in any column and expect them to add up nicely.

It’s easy to focus on the “horse race” elements of presidential politics – and I’ve been exasperated when I hear millenials (perhaps nonrepresentative) quoted in radio interviews suggesting that there is little difference between Clinton and Trump.  There is a world of difference, and this microsimulation helps illustrate what this could mean to real people in 2018.