Tampilkan postingan dengan label California. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label California. Tampilkan semua postingan

Rabu, 07 Juni 2017

Don't hold your breath for single payer




Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is $400 Billion


Health Insurer Market Caps as of 6/5/17 Source  

While the Republicans in the Senate are trying to figure out how to pass TrumpCare without being tagged for causing loss of insurance for tens of millions - Democrats are pushing for single payer health care in a way we haven't seen since the 1970s.  

The New York Times headline:
The Single-Payer Party? Democrats Shift Left on Health Care
A Republican writes in the Washington Post:
The momentum for socialized medicine is growing. Where is the GOP’s strategy?

California's Assembly is debating a serious bill to move to single payer health care -- although the bill passed the State Senate without a funding mechanism.   Current estimates suggest that the bill would cost $400 billion a year - more than twice the current state budget.  This problem scuttled efforts to pass single payer health care in Vermont last year.

Nevada's House and Senate passed a bill to allow those with income under 400% of the Federal Poverty Limit to purchase Medicaid rather than an ObamaCare plan - which could be a low cost way to get to a public option.

There are good reasons to support single payer health care -which need not mean a government "takeover" of health care delivery (as is true in the United Kingdom and Cuba).   Most developed countries which have single payer health care pool funds for health care across the entire population, and use intermediaries to actually pay independent providers (hospitals, doctors, pharmacies, etc) for their services.  Mark Bertolini, Aetna's CEO, suggested that the US should have the single payer debate, reminding employees at a private gathering that "Aetna was the first financial intermediary for Medicare. We cut the first check for Medicare in 1965 to Hartford Hospital for $517.57."  Source 

Advantages of a single payer system could include

  • Lower administrative costs (for both payers and providers)
  • More purchasing power - leading to lower prices
  • A unified risk pool - so that there would likely be less effort to shift risk
  • More imperative to purchase based on value - which would also decrease price and utilization for lower value services
  • Simplification of our finance system in general would lead to fewer intermediaries and less transactional cost

But there are also powerful reasons why single payer is terribly unlikely to prevail in the United States

  • Almost a fifth of the economy remains reasonably happy in the current system.   Physicians are largely well paid, and hospitals are the center of wealth for many communities.  All those lower prices look good for purchasers - but if we started paying hospitals the prices paid in other developed countries, there would be massive layoffs.
  • The market capitalization for the top four national health insurers alone is almost a third of a trillion dollars.  It won't be easy to pass legislation and regulations to take away their business! Kaiser Permanente, a nonprofit and the largest nongovernmental employer in California, is vehemently opposed to single payer in  its main market.
  • Americans deeply distrust government -- and are reluctant to support increased government role
  • Any such massive reorganization of so much of our economy will have winners and losers - and the losers will be much more vocal than the winners.

Single payer done state-by-state is also less likely with a conservative Republican administration, which could without Medicare and Medicaid waivers which would mean the states would have to fund a larger portion of the total bill.  

Perhaps most of all, employers pay almost a trillion dollars annually for health care for their employees. Some employers  cherish the ability to arrange high value health care coverage for their employees, and have established the organizational knowledge and infrastructure to do this.  But many others would be happy to focus their attention on their core businesses - and be out of health care altogether.  

But extracting the $1 trillion from employers to fund health care - that would be very difficult. I've been pretty much convinced it can't be done - but circumstances change so it's worth thinking about how this could be accomplished:


Advantages
Challenges
Payroll tax
    • Collects money from businesses en lieu of current employer health care costs
    • Would mean higher cost for high wage employers - which could be addressed through a cap.
    • Might not be able to collect enough from low wage employers- although their employees were often on public assistance before
    • Likely to be opposed by employers - especially those who believed that it would cost more than they currently spend on health care
Per worker fee
    • Mirrors current cost  structure
    • Would be difficult to implement for lower wage workers -and could hasten automation to avoid employing low wage workers
    • Likely to be opposed by employers - especially those who believed that it would cost more than they currently spend on health care
Consumption tax (like value added tax - VAT)
    • Less likely to be opposed by employers
    • Difficult to make progressive as those with low wages spend more of their available resources on necessities
    • Highly visible -  would raise apparent prices on virtually everything
    • Could be paired with an increase in the earned income tax credit or decreased taxes for those with low wages
    • Could exclude reasonable priced necessities from the tax
Income tax
    • Perhaps less likely to be opposed by business
    • Would allow progressivity (subsidy from the wealthy to those of moderate income)

    • Economists believe that in the long run worker income would go up if cost of benefits declined - but in the short run this would lead to dramatic decrease in worker take-home pay
    • Income taxes poll near Ebola in popularity

I'm still not convinced the time is ripe in the US to promote single payer health care.   But most other developed countries have just that, and deliver higher value at lower cost.   We've seen the dramatic changes in federal policies from a single election where the prevailing candidate won substantially less than half the vote and the winning party lost House and Senate seats, so a "wave" election could lead to dramatic changes in what is possible.

Rabu, 05 April 2017

Prices matter


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is $356,884.42


There are two articles in the news this week that show that price matters. (Not Tom Price, the HHS Secretary, who also matters!).

Elisabeth Rosenthal, long-time NY Times reporter who is now the editor in chief of Kaiser Health News, has an article in the NY Time Magazine “Those Indecipherable Health Care Bills: They’re One Reason Health Care Costs So Much.”  

Wanda Wickizer awoke from her brain bleed with months of recovery ahead of her. She lost her insurance after her husband died, and found bills including:
·        $356,884.42 from the hospital
·        $50,000 for the air ambulance
·        $78,000 from the medical group for professional services
·        $16,000 from the emergency department
Rosenthal reviews the history of medical coding and the escalating battle between providers – who use codes to upgrade their fees – and insurance companies, which use the same codes to cut fees down.  Left out of this battle altogether are those who have no insurance company to run interference with them.  Even with a team of expert volunteers, Wickizer had a hard time figuring out her inscrutable bills –and had little luck negotiating decreases.

Hospitals often say that their “chargemasters,” which are the “rack rates” or “asking price,” are irrelevant since no one pays them anyway.    

But that’s not true.

Research published in Health Affairs on Monday demonstrates that hospitals which increase their chargemaster by a dollar receive an extra 15 cents in revenue.  So – someone IS paying these rack rates!    The research also shows that when California prohibited billing more than Medicare rates to those without insurance who had incomes under 350% of the federal poverty limit, the actual amount paid by uninsured patients of modest income decreased dramatically.

By the way, the researchers also investigated whether higher chargemasters were associated with better quality.    There was no association.

This is solid evidence that some type of price ceiling could lower the actual cost of medical care in the US – because the price charged does indeed matter


This shows that when chargemasters increased, the uninsured paid much more in California before 2007, and did not subsequently   Source

Senin, 07 November 2016

California Ballot Initiative Aims to Lower Drug Prices

California Ballot Initiative Aims to Lower Drug Prices


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 61



California will vote on Proposition 61 tomorrow; the ballot initiative would mandate that California pay no more than the Veteran’s Administration (VA) for pharmaceutical prices.   This would apply to $3.8 billion in drug spending by Medical (California’s Medicaid program), state workers, and retirees.  It’s an unworkable proposal –but still could achieve its goals.

Health Affairs has a blog post explaining the measure, which is being opposed by the Pharma industry (over $100 million in expected spending), and promoted by the California Nurses Association, the AIDS HealthCare Foundation, the California AARP and others.   It’s also opposed by the LA Times and the SF Chronicle,

The measure is unworkable because

1.     The VA has a limited formulary – so can negotiate lower prices.   Medicaid rules prevent the state from having a limited formulary for non-managed Medicaid.
2.     There are NO VA prices for the drugs not in its formulary –so the measure would fail to control the prices of those drugs.
3.     The state doesn’t have the ability to force drug companies to sell their products at the mandated price, which could lead to shortages or drugs being unavailable.

The measure is economically unwise because mandating a “most favored nation (MFN)  price generally increases the price for all purchasers.   When Medicaid MFN was introduced in the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1990,  it raised the overall price of drugs by about 4%- because having to give a rebate to Medicaid whenever a private payer struck a good deal helped the pharmaceutical companies enforce price discipline.   Here’s a link to a 2010 blog post on this subject .

But still. 

This ballot initiative puts pressure on pharmaceutical companies to keep prices lower, and puts pressure on the state as a purchaser to negotiate hard.  Its authors might realize the measure would be almost impossible to enforce –but are looking to draw public attention as part of a campaign to control drug prices.  

There is an analogous example about how the initial“Romneycare” health care reform was passed in Massachusetts.  Unions and the advocacy group Health Care for All had the support to place a constitutional amendment on the ballot to guarantee access to affordable comprehensive health care.   The health care reform that passed was much more acceptable to the system stakeholders than this ballot initiative – and so reform moved forward. 

Senin, 12 September 2016

California passes legislation to prevent surprise medical bills

California passes legislation to prevent surprise medical bills


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 72


National Public Radio reported yesterday on recently passed bipartisan California legislation, AB-72, awaiting Governor Jerry Brown’s signature. This bill would protect patients from “surprise” medical bills when they receive care at “in network” facilities which have “out of network” individual physicians who provider services.

Health plans often cannot achieve affordable contracts with certain specialties which often have geographic monopolies.  When patients receive medical care at an in-network facility but one of the providers is out of network, they often are responsible for paying the provider’s full billed charges unless they can negotiate a discount. Patients have little leverage to negotiate a substantial discount after the procedure has already happened.

Public outcry is often directed at the health plans when patients get an outlandish bill from an anesthesiologist  or other specialist who is out of network, but the underlying problem is the very high fee schedules from these out of network providers.  Simply saying the health plans should pay the out of plan providers in full helps get the (often sick) patient out of the middle –but also has the potential to cause further escalation in health care costs.  Further, such a move could encourage more physicians to remain out of network – which could cause additional access concerns.

The California legislation addresses this concern by creating a ceiling for out of network provider charges – at the higher of the average in-network charge or 125% of Medicare. This means that no expensive, time-consuming and futile negotiation with the out-of-network providers is required of the health plan or the patient. If the provider refuses to be in network, the most she can charge is 125% of Medicare.

The legislation allows out-of-network physicians to bill patients for their full charges IF the patient signs a waiver to agree to pay out-of-network rates . The waiver must be signed 24 hours before a procedure, be separate from any other informed consent, and be accompanied by an estimate of the charges.   This would need to be enforced so that facilities with out-of-network providers didn’t simply present such waivers to all patients on a routine basis.

The legislation also requires health plans to keep accurate lists of participating providers, and to provide a full range of in-network providers at each participating facility.  (That would be hard where the health plan cannot get to “yes” with an anesthesiology group – we’ll have to see how the regulations are written.  Capping bills at 125% of Medicare might be enough to insure access and affordability even where the health plan cannot achieve a contract with certain specialists.)

Kaiser Family Foundation found that 7 in 10 individuals with unaffordable out-of-plan medical bills didn’t know the provider was out of plan when they received care, and these out of plan charges were a prominent factor in insured patients struggling with medical debt.  Consumer Reports has promoted efforts to prevent such surprise medical bills across the country.   CR notes that a number of states have language requiring advance notice or dispute resolution, but often have little enforcement mechanism.

Modern Healthcare suggests that this bill is likely to be a model for other states – as well it should be.   

Don't celebrate too much, though.   State regulation generally does not provide protections to the 63% of those with self-funded employer-sponsored health insurance. Providing protection for this large group of patients will require federal legislation or regulatory action.