Tampilkan postingan dengan label AHCA. Tampilkan semua postingan
Tampilkan postingan dengan label AHCA. Tampilkan semua postingan

Kamis, 06 Juli 2017

TrumpCare: Defective insurance plans to fleece policyholders




Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is  49.5%


As Kim Jung Un fires ballistic missiles into the waters off Japan and Donald Trump encourages the right wing in Poland, the Senate continues to work under the cover of heavy secrecy on a bill to strip health care from tens of millions. 

But that's not enough.   In the name of free markets, Ted Cruz has suggested that insurance companies should be allowed to sell insurance plans that do not comply with pre-existing condition prohibitions or offer all ACA-required essential benefits  - as long as in each state they offer at least one plan that does comply with ACA requirements. 

Here's how this would work.   Insurers would offer one plan that complied with the Affordable Care Act.  This plan would  cover maternity (just think!), mental health services, ambulance rides, prescription drugs, and emergency rooms. (All of these requirements would be waived in the non-compliant plans).   The plan would be available for the same price to all comers, whether they were healthy or had preexisting illnesses.  The plan would be attractive to those at high risk - so it would have to have a high price.  It would also likely be saddled with the largest allowable deductibles and coinsurance - to discourage utilization and to keep the premium from being even higher.   

This plan is the definition of a "death spiral."  Insurers would offer compliant plans to gain the right to offer the less inclusive plans, which would be priced to sell.   Risk for having babies or taking expensive medicines would be transferred to individuals - as healthy members would no longer be subsidizing the sick.    Those with preexisting illnesses could choose between affording their housing or their health insurance. 

What would noncompliant insurance look like for those at low risk who could make it through the underwriting process to gain eligibility?  For starters, it would be cheap!   Five percent of the population represents49.5% of all medical costs - so you could design an insurance plan for 40% less if you could exclude those expensive patients - and still make a whopping profit.  But Mitch McConnell will focus on the lower prices, not he value of the available plans.     

However that noncompliant plan would be a bum deal.   It could be a "mini-med" plan which had a cap of a few thousand dollars - enough for an emergency room visit.  (These were banned by the ACA - but would be revived under Trumpcare).   It would exclude specialty medications which often cost $100,000 a year, and would not cover mental health services.  It would be designed to be unattractive to those with real needs -because that's how to make such a plan profitable.  Do you need maternity care?  Then buy a rider priced at the cost of delivery!


These plans would have very low "medical loss ratios."   Under the ACA, insurers must issue refunds if their administrative costs exceed 15-20%.   Those rebates would go away - and insurance company profitability would soar.   That's why health plans are ambivalent about TrumpCare.  They hate going back to offering plans designed to exclude coverage for the sick - but those profits are mighty attractive.

Even worse, the bottom 50% of the population represents under 3% of total costs.   Imagine how cheap the health plan catering to just the healthiest half of the population could be - while leaving room for healthy profits. 
  
We don't allow automakers to sell cars without bumpers.  We don't allow furniture makers to sell baby cribs that have risk of finger amputation or decapitation.  The government has a role in promoting public safety -and this role includes structuring markets to prevent the sale of defective or dangerous goods.  

There's no reason to allow the resurrection of insurance plans that fleece  policyholders and leave sick people with no coverage.  The Senate should reject this terrible idea.

Selasa, 23 Mei 2017

Trump budget would worsen American health


.
Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is $1.5 Trillion


The Trump budget is out today, and the Congressional Budget Office report on the House-passed American Health Care Act is due tomorrow.    It's a big week for policy nerds, and a terrible weak for the less fortunate among us. 

There's a lot to unpack in the Trump budget plan -which assumes growth rates that have not been achieved by developed countries, drives huge tax cuts to the richest Americans, violates a host of campaign promises, and double counts extra tax revenue from growth. But the cuts in our safety net, which is already less robust than most developed countries, would cause staggering worsening of the overall health of Americans.

Among the cuts proposed by the Trump Administration:

  • $6 billion cut in the National Institutes of Health.   The NIH funds the most important groundbreaking basic and applied science research.   We can't cure cancer without the NIH.  Here's a review of research showing that NIH funding actually leads to more value than the underlying spending.
  • Cut Medicaid by 47%, or about $1.5 trillion over a decade.  This is $660 billion cut on top of the devastating cuts already in the AHCA which alone would have led to more than 14 million Americans losing access to health insurance.  Medicaid already covers almost half of all births in the US (70% in Louisiana)    But 2/3 of Medicaid spending historically has been for the elderly and disabled.   Medicaid is the largest purchaser of nursing home beds.  The Trump budget promises to leave untouched the elderly and the disabled.  But the algebra doesn't work - you can't cut half the budget while telling those who represent 2/3 of the costs that they will escape harm.    Here's a summary from statnews.com  on where Medicaid spends its dollars, and from vox.com on the potential impact of these cuts.
  • 29% cut in food stamps (Supplementary Nutritional Assistance Program).   Food stamps now allow about $2 per meal.  There will be many more children going hungry!
  • 19% cut in Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP).   We have uninsured rate among children at an all-time low - and this is clearly at risk.
  • 13% cut in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
  • 12% cut in unemployment insurance
  • 8% decrease in earned income tax credit

The Trump budget funds huge tax cuts by ripping away the social safety net that is critical to population health.   This is especially ironic, as  the world is recognizing that changes in the workplace might make a universal basic income a necessity.  Yesterday's post shows that our health access and quality is far worse than other countries.   Irresponsible cuts like this are likely to cause huge and unnecessary human tragedy, and to make our subsequent scores even worse.

Senin, 08 Mei 2017

Nine TrumpCare Lies

Nine TrumpCare Lies


Today's Managing Health Care Costs Number is 9


The Republicans hit the talk shows and the radio waves this weekend to defend the indefensible American Health Care Act (AHCA).  There are lies everywhere - making the moniker "TrumpCare" totally appropriate.  Here are five key recurrent lies:

Lie One: At least the AHCA will lower the cost of health care. 
No such luck. There is nothing in the bill that would lower the cost of actually delivering health care; at least the ACA had alternative payment models  and the CMS innovation center and pathway for approval of bioequivalent drugs.  The CBO estimatesthat the premiums will actually increase by 15-20% by 2019.  Premiums will be lower in 2026 not because costs have been averted, but because sick people will be priced out of the market. 

Lie Two:  The AHCA will have no impact on employer-sponsored health insurance .
Au contraire.  Employer mandate will be eliminated, and employers will be able to  base their benefits on a benchmark plan that from a state that has opted out of essential benefits and doesn't require coverage of preexisting conditions or  prohibit annual and lifetime maximums. Further, those covered by employer sponsored health insurance will be more reluctant to leave their jobs (whether to start a new business or retire early) since the individual market will be back to its dysfunctional pre-Obamacare state, where only healthy people qualify for insurance.  Most employers will not want to go back to the pre-ACA policies - but the most vulnerable are those in low skill low wage industries where workers most need the protection they will likely lose.

Lie Three: No states will opt out of the ACA essential benefits and preexisting condition rules anyway.
Bullsh#t.   Tom Reed, a New York representative, said this on NPR on Saturday.  If no states would opt out, there'd be no reason to include this clause in the legislation.  Look at the 19 states that have harmed their residents by not expanding Medicaid.  States will be lobbied hard by various business interests to eliminate these requirements - and all it takes is a single state to opt out to mean that self-insured plans across the country can eliminate this required coverage. 

Lie Four:  We are not going to kick people off Medicaid!
Really? Then where is that $880 billion of savings coming from?  Remember that the majority of Medicaid spending is on the elderly and dual-eligibles (those with disabilities) - and it's hard to kick grandma out of a nursing home. The impact on Medicaid for poor people is likely to be far worse.  "Grandfathering" current Medicaid beneficiaries isn't so helpful when 1/3 cycle in and out of Medicaid eligibility each year.   Don't forget - Medicaid covers about half of all births in the US!

Lie Five: High risk pools will protect those with preexisting illnesses

High risk pools are invariably subject to "death spiral" where they are so expensive that all but the sickest decide not to sign up - making them  even more expensive in subsequent years.  The only way to make high risk pools work is with massive public subsidies, and there is widespread agreement that the AHCA offers too little.   Representative Fred Upton's $8 billion in additional funds (over 3 years) is not nearly enough.  

Lie Six: No one dies because they don't have access to health care.

Raul Labrador (R, Idaho) was roundly booed when he asserted this at a town hall this weekend.  Researchers suggest somewhere between 24,000 and 48,000 a year would die because of the "old" AHCA -before it was made worse by the new amendments

Lie Seven: The Senate will never pass this intemperate and ill-considered bill.

One thing we've learned in the past year is that we can't count on traditional political wisdom.  The White House cares about wins, and promotes the AHCA as a distraction from other issues  including Russia, environmental degradation, and corruption.  Anyone who thinks the Senate could never pass such a destructive bill should reconsider- and remember that the eventual Senate bill will be compared to the AHCA, not to optimal health care policy that maximizes coverage and value purchased.  The House moderates would never have voted for the AHCA. And then, after a few cosmetic billion in funding for high risk pools, they fell into line.

Lie Eight: The Obamacare exchanges are failing.

There are problems with the exchanges - and most of these are generated by decisions made by state regulators (which allowed sales of non-exchange products that skim off the healthy) or by Congress (which removed risk corridor funding) or the Trump Administration (which has signaled it won't enforce the individual mandate and is daring the insurers to abandon the market by failing to commit to cost sharing reduction payments required by law).

Lie Nine:
This is all about health care policy.

Not really.   The AHCA is a tax cut of close to a trillion dollars that will almost all go to the most wealthy.  Those with income of over $1m will on average gain a $50,000 tax cut; those   The Republicans desperately want to deliver that tax cut - and will tolerate almost immeasurable damage to the health care system to do it.  

Senin, 27 Maret 2017

The AHCA is dead, but Trump could still kill the ACA


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is Six



We can spend the weekend celebrating the failure of Congressional Republicans to repeal and replace Obamacare.   The American Health Care Act was ill-conceived, would have led to loss of insurance for 24 million, and would have led to higher health care costs and less meaningful health insurance coverage for additional millions – and it is dead.  For now.

But the opportunity to damage the Affordable Care Act remains. 

Salonhas an insightful piece today about how the Republicans have been undermining the ACA since it was passed.  Marco Rubio and others slipped a provision into a budget bill that gutted risk corridor payments to health plans that lost money in the ACA’s early years, when actuaries lacked enough claims to make good estimates of projected costs.   The federal government owed insurers $2.9 million, but only paid out $400,000.   This was a major reason for the failure of the COOP plans, and a lawsuit on this was dismissed last week.

There are many other ways that the Trump Administration can undermine the Affordable Care Act, and help fulfill Donald Trump’s predictions about the ACA “imploding” or “exploding.”   Today, I’ll focus on what the administration can do to undermine the law – and in a future post I’ll talk more about what it could do to make the law work better.  

1.      Stop paying insurance plans for the “cost reduction subsidy,” the CSR.   The ACA limits out of pocket spending for individuals at under 250% of the federal poverty limit, and the federal government writes a check to health plans to cover this expense.   The expense is not factored into premium costs.  But the House Republicans sued the Obama Administration - asserting that it could only pay these funds if they were appropriated.    A district court found for the House, and the Obama Administration lodged an appeal.   The Trump administration and Paul Ryan have asked the Appeals Court to delay hearing the case.  If the Trump Administration decides not to defend against this suit and to renege on payment to health plans – we’re going to see a mass exodus of insurers from the ACA marketplaces.

Source:



2.       Not enforce the employer mandate
One of the biggest impacts of the ACA was that it set standards for “minimum essential coverage,” and employers had to meet those standards or would be subject to penalties. These penalties were delayed by the Obama Administration (although it’s not clear they had the authority to do so.)  But there has been widespread belief that employers that did offer the ten essential benefits as required by each state, or had premiums that were unaffordable for their employees, would have to pay a penalty someday.  If it’s clear there will never be a penalty, we could lose many of the benefits of a national standard for employer sponsored health insurance.

3.      Not enforce the individual mandate
We need to have healthy people in the insurance pool, because insurance is wealth transfer from the healthy to the sick.   Many healthy people (yup – guys in their 20s) feel invincible – so there has to be some “stick” to encourage them to sign up for (and pay for) health insurance.   Hence the reviled mandate.  The Trump administration has already instructed the IRS not to collect data from individuals documenting health coverage.   Further moves to telegraph that the requirement is dead could help make all of the “death spiral” talk a reality. 

4.      Give states Medicaid waivers that allow them to sharply diminish the numbers of those covered, or the quality of the coverage.  Medicaid is the most cost effective way to cover the poor – and is far less expensive than commercial insurance, generally due to low provider fees.   States have asked for waivers to require work, to require more cost sharing, and to require more bureaucracy.   These efforts will push many away from Medicaid – which will lead to worse health outcomes and expose providers to bad debt.

5.      Cancel marketing plans.   The Affordable Care Act works to reduce uninsurance when there is aggressive marketing. The Trump Administration pulled ads at the end of the last enrollment period, and when they pulled ads, enrollment dropped.  The ACA only succeeds with robust enrollment.  It won’t work if the ACA is a closely guarded secret.

6.      Abandon payment reform.  Let’s face it- the real problem with the ACA is that health care is too expensive.  I don’t believe for a minute that payment reform will by itself cure our health care cost problem.  But I believe that aggressive experimentation with different payment models can help drive clinical transformation.  Medicare is a critical player in payment reform, and the efforts of CMS and CMMI (Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation) have helped foment substantial payment reform on the commercial side.  However, if providers generally think that the Tom Price HHS doesn’t care for any payment reform, we could see a substantial drop in provider ACO activity.  Providers who continue to do what they have historically done are not going to help us control health care costs.  

It was easy for the Republicans to vociferously oppose the Affordable Care Act, but hard for them to agree on a meaningful alternative.   It was easier for the Democrats to oppose the poorly-drafted AHCA, and will be harder for them to push the executive branch to do effective rule-making and enforcement now that Ryan and Trump have agreed that the ACA is the "law of the land."


Additional sources for this post are articles by Margot Katz-Sanger of the New York Times, Anna Maria Barry-Jester of 538.comand Adam Cancryn and others of Politico.

Image (C) cmfu via Flickr Creative Common License  

Rabu, 22 Maret 2017

Medicaid work requirements a bad idea

Medicaid work requirements a bad idea



Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 15%


The AHCA is headed toward a vote in the House of Representatives tomorrow night – although many oddsmakers say that Paul Ryan does not have the votes to pass the bill,  and it’s more likely to be held over for further overhaul before a vote.  The bill would likely make worse just about every problem its authors say intends to fix – so any delay is good.

One recent concession to conservatives, who would like the government out of health care finance altogether, is allowing states to require work of nondisabled adults who receive Medicaid. 

This idea “feels” fair.  Here’s a paragraph from the beginning of Brooke Gladstone’s excellent “Busted, America’s Poverty Myths” from On the Media this past fall:

A recent poll conducted by the LA Times and the conservative American Enterprise Institute finds that roughly 87% of Americans, including 81% of those below the poverty line, believe that requiring poor people to seek work or training in return for benefits is better than providing aid without asking for anything in return. And that’s pretty much what we found as we hopped from Cleveland to Appalachia to Columbus on our poverty tour.

But it’s a terrible idea.  Here’s an explanation from a later episode of Busted of why a job requirement for poverty programs are not useful:

Well, aside from there not being enough jobs that pay above the poverty line, the vast majority just can't work because the Census Bureau says that a quarter of the poor are kids, roughly 14% are elderly, 13% disabled, 9% are engaged in caring for someone full-time, 8% are students and 16% percent are already fully employed. That’s 85%. The remainder includes many workers who are suffering through a dry spell in a bad market. We could move them into work if we covered their basic expenses and training and helped them find jobs, but we don't.

Work requirements are a way of stigmatizing the poor, and are likely to disrupt access to care to many disabled Americans.  Administrative costs go up, and access is diminished for the most needy.  Hopefully, even this egregious plan won’t mollify the conservative Freedom Caucus, leaving the AHCA short of the required 216 votes to pass.

Senin, 20 Maret 2017

Death Panel of 535 -how many the AHCA will kill


Today’s Managing Health Care Costs Number is 24,000

Via Flickr creative commons license 

As the scheduled House of Representatives vote on the American Health Care Act is only 3 days away, and as Paul Ryan continues to tweak the legislation to satisfy conservatives (who want deeper cuts in Medicaid) and moderates (who want to make the bill less dreadful for those over 50), it’s worth looking back at research that shows how much insurance matters.

The AHCA if passed is expected to lead to an excess of between 24,000 and 48,000 deaths per year.

Julia Belluz did a  review of the work of Ben Sommers and others about a week ago on Vox.com – reprising work she did a month earlier. Giving people insurance decreases mortality.   

A New England Journal 2012 study said that 20 lives were saved annually per 100,000 who were newly enrolled in Medicaid. A 2014 study in Annals of Internal Medicine showed that health care reform in Massachusetts decreased mortality by 2.9% in the state compared to a control state that did not do health care reform in 2006 –a decrease in mortality of 8 per 100,000 insured.  

New research published in the Annals of Internal Medicineshows that cystic fibrosis patients live 10 years longer in Canada than in the United States.   Those with insurance in the US have life expectancy similar to CF sufferers north of our border.  Mortality is dramatically higher in those who are uninsured.

Median age of survival in patients with cystic fibrosis increased in both countries between 1990 and 2013; however, in 1995 and 2005, survival in Canada increased at a faster rate than in the United States (P < 0.001). On the basis of contemporary data from 2009 to 2013, the median age of survival in Canada was 10 years greater than in the United States (50.9 vs. 40.6 years, respectively). The adjusted risk for death was 34% lower in Canada than the United States (hazard ratio, 0.66 [95% CI, 0.54 to 0.81]). A greater proportion of patients in Canada received transplants (10.3% vs. 6.5%, respectively [standardized difference, 13.7]). Differences in survival between U.S. and Canadian patients varied according to U.S. patients' insurance status.

It seems like a pretty terrible time to kick 24 million people off insurance!  Of course, you don't need to read medical journals to know that!

Throughout the 2009 debate on the Affordable Care Act, there were false claims that the ACA included "death panels."  The real death panel, it turns out, is the members of the US House and Senate.  Let's hope they make the right decision.